A Minnesota fish feud over muskie stocking has been settled — for now — with a decision by the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) to introduce the big predators to the Gull Lake chain around Nisswa, but not in lakes near Fergus Falls in Otter Tail County or in Big Marine Lake in the metro area.
Adding muskies to two lake chains was widely seen as a victory for muskie anglers, a group the DNR has described as the fastest growing segment of Minnesota sport fishing.
The announcement was a relief to residents of Otter Tail County who aggressively opposed the expansion of muskellunge out of fear that it would damage cherished populations of walleye and panfish. On Gull Lake, the DNR said, opposition was less vehement.
In either case, the agency has more work to do in convincing the public of its belief that muskies can coexist with other sport fish without eating them or hogging the food supply in a given lake, DNR fisheries chief Don Pereira said.
"We need to work more with stakeholders," Pereira said. "We've learned we can stock these fish" without harming others.
Monday's announcement capped a two-year public input period that was prolonged for six months by controversy. At the Legislature this year, elected officials unsuccessfully sought to block the DNR from adding to the muskie's range.
At Big Marine, two local governments voiced opposition to muskies along with the lake's Disabled Veterans Rest Camp, a group that hosts injured vets on fishing retreats.
But Pereira said the ultimate decision to remove Big Marine from consideration was a closer look at the lake's biology. He said researchers found signs of decline in forage fish, possibly from northerns.