Bruce Taher stood on the creaking porch that wraps around Forepaugh’s restaurant, surveying St. Paul’s Irvine Park neighborhood.
The restaurant was darkened, as it had been since he shuttered it in 2019. The foundation was cracking beneath him, thanks to the encroaching root system of a neighbor’s tree. The grand chandelier was robbed of its sparkle under decades of dust, the carpet was spotted with memories of meals dating back to the 1980s and the carport patio sagged. And, if mediums are to be believed, the spirits long rumored to occupy this house roamed without anyone to tell their stories. Taher eased back on his heels and sighed to his executive corporate chef, “I think I’m falling in love with this building again.”
The undertaking of properly bringing this stately home-turned-restaurant back to its glory would not be easy.
“It’s been 19 months of loving restoration,” said executive corporate chef John Sugimura, who has led the project on behalf of Taher. “Nothing was easy about it, but we’re renovating it, stabilizing it and making sure it’s a treasure in the neighborhood.”
He’s since led scores of impromptu tours through the grand mansion’s many rooms, which have been repainted, scrubbed and recarpeted.
Among those who recall fond memories of this place is St. Paul native and James Beard Award-winning chef Tim McKee. “You know, there were two places to go for all the big events growing up; graduations, confirmations, prom. It was Forepaugh’s or the Lex. I’m so glad Bruce is bringing this back,” he said.
McKee has been brought on to consult on the menu and rebuild the kitchen team. The chef is familiar with working within a historic building, having made his name at the landmark restaurant La Belle Vie, which he operated on the ground floor of Minneapolis’ 510 Groveland building.
To run day-to-day operations, McKee tapped Jeremy Wessing, who worked with him at Sea Change and has since been in the kitchen at notable spots like Baldamar and Pau Hana. There will be two menus, one with small plates that diners can order in the bar, on the porch or up on the deck. Another will be served in the dining rooms. Food will be familiar American dishes with a little bit of an Italian bent. There will be pasta.