Perhaps it was the “exotic” name — turkey tetrazzini — as well as its ease of preparation that made it my mom’s signature casserole.
The recipe is said to be named for Luisa Tetrazzini, an Italian opera star at the turn of the 20th century. Who created it is widely disputed, with stories crediting chefs in New York City and San Francisco. The dish certainly sounds more interesting than its humble assemblage of leftover turkey, noodles and cheese. It was what Mom brought to bridal and baby showers, funerals and neighborhood potlucks because it can be made ahead to warm up and is easy to serve.
I grew up in New Jersey, where any meal served from one deep baking dish was called a casserole. The term “hot dish” was a revelation, the perfect moniker for this simple, thrifty and creative use of the odds and ends of a previous dinner.
Credit the Mankato Grace Lutheran Ladies Aid Cookbook for publishing the first official recipe in the 1930s. The traditional mix of protein, starch and vegetables bound in a creamy sauce and baked off until bubbly became especially popular during World War I and fed families during the Great Depression. It was and still is an inexpensive way to stretch the kitchen’s bounty.
Turkey Tetrazzini is perfect for a “meal train” dinner delivered to families with a new baby or when one is ill. And it’s just the dish to make ahead and tote to a ski weekend up north or share at a neighborhood potluck.
It’s one of those no-recipe recipes to make on the fly when it’s brutally cold and going out seems out of the question. It can be whipped up with an assortment of pantry staples — substitute canned tuna for the turkey, use frozen vegetables for the peppers, if you’re out of spaghetti, use rice, etc. All you really need is a baking dish. Hot dish, done!
Turkey Tetrazzini
(Serves 4 to 6 and is easily doubled)
A winter classic, this hot dish is perfect for meal train assignments, potlucks and informal gatherings. It can be made a day ahead and heated right before serving. While the recipe calls for turkey, leftover chicken (especially rotisserie chicken) works beautifully, too. From Beth Dooley.