Opinion editor’s note: Star Tribune Opinion publishes a mix of national and local commentaries online and in print each day. To contribute, click here.
•••
In response to Star Tribune columnist Evan Ramstad’s “Choosing to self-segregate in schools” (Aug. 11), let me suggest a hybrid model for public education that offers the best of both worlds: competitive schools for families that want their children to “get ahead” (that should be everyone), and community schools for families that want their children to get along well with their neighbors and be good members of the community (that should also be everyone).
Competition is good for individuals and institutions alike. How does this work on the battlefield that public schools find themselves on? Competition within and among public school districts via open enrollment results in certain schools with higher reputations that rise to the top. And competition between public and private schools helps keep all educators on their toes.
But competition means we have winners and losers, and we should have reservations about what this means. If all the children from good and caring families transfer to schools with the strongest reputation, are we not left with all the children from the less able or less engaged families in the bad schools in weaker districts? We then end up with an awful lot of kids who, through no fault of their own, will be stuck in poor facilities that lack resources with overworked and sometimes burnt-out teachers. This seems like a surefire way to set them up for failure later in life.
On the other end of the spectrum, as stronger schools become ever more competitive, the more elite the school, the more insulated their students become from the rest of the world. What colors their perception of the world around them?
Perhaps it’s time to add an entirely new layer to public education — the community school.
Community schools (CS) would focus on community-building skills. Interpersonal skills like belonging, nurturing, caregiving and compassion. Cooperative skills — how to be a good citizen, a solid member of the community and environmentally conscious. CS would teach children about the connection between rights and privileges on the one hand, and civic and social responsibilities on the other.