"Even to friends, Chauvin was an enigma in blue" (front page, Aug. 9) reveals important perspectives on the type of police officer Derek Chauvin was but draws the wrong conclusion. The article's testimonials describe him as not "overly aggressive" for the force, a normal "face in the crowd" of Minneapolis officers, while simultaneously concluding that something "happened to him" and that he somehow went rogue. Not only is this a blatant contradiction, but it misses the opportunity to demonstrate the problem with policing in this country: Having 17 misconduct complaints is viewed as normal and a man who can behave as Chauvin did toward George Floyd didn't previously stand out from his fellow officers.
To conclude from these testimonials that Chauvin went rogue is a problem with the reporting of policing. It is, to borrow a word from Trevor Noah, "copaganda." Chauvin's unremarkable record, coupled with the recently reported data that Black people make up 78% of vehicle searches conducted by the Minneapolis Police Department (front page, Aug. 7), should lead a reasonable person to conclude that there is racism and violence deeply embedded within the MPD. Chauvin is the most clear-cut example, but, as activists and protesters have been telling us, the problem runs far deeper than just one bad apple.
Matthew Ruppert, Edina
• • •
Read this passage from a May 28 Star Tribune article very carefully: " 'I don't think the paramedics knew what was going on. They just saw a split second of what was happening,' [the Hennepin Healthcare EMS chief] said in reference to Chauvin's prolonged knee restraint on Floyd's neck. 'Ultimately, if the police have somebody in custody, we have to get permission from them to work with on the patient.' "
Does this mean that no human — be they physician, medic, first aid attendant, EMS, nurse, health care aide or a concerned member of the public — can direct, instruct, order, demand or insist that a public servant allow for medical assistance to be rendered for a person in their charge?
How much power over human life do the police need in order to perform their public duties?
Lawrence Crosthwaite, Ponoka, Alberta
• • •
In response to an Aug. 9 letter in which the writer states that he "inflicted more stress than [he] suffered" in Vietnam and wonders if the same might be true of Minneapolis police officers now making claims of post-traumatic stress disorder:
I wonder how much stress you could inflict if, when you went into battle, your commanding officer said to you: "When they start shooting and throwing grenades, I want you to stand there and take it, because you do realize that these are peaceful enemies [the protesters]." I am a vet, too. If you have no stress related to those days, count your blessings — at least you were in a position to defend yourself.
Lowell A Geske, Rosemount
EDMUND BURKE
France then and America now
I concur with Bret Stephens' comparison of America's current revolutionary fervor with the French Revolution (Opinion Exchange, Aug. 9). But Edmund Burke's warning needs an international audience as well.