Thursday morning, several young composers stood outside Osmo Vänskä's studio at Orchestra Hall. They were awaiting, joked Eugene Birman of Oxford, England, "The judgment of Caesar."
Actually, they were lined up for one-on-one critiques of their scores by Vänskä, the orchestra's musical director. In town for the weeklong Minnesota Orchestra Composer Institute that culminates Friday night in a concert of their work, the emerging composers from across the United States and Sweden were about to hear their pieces played by a top symphony orchestra.
"I'm at an early stage in my career — I'm 27 — and musicians at this level of artistry have been practicing my work for two months," Birman said.
In its 12th year, the Composer Institute is known as one of the premiere showcases of contemporary classical music. It's part of the reason Minnesota has won the Leonard Bernstein Awards for Education Programming three times, more than any other orchestra. Several past attendees, including Anna Clyne and Ted Hearne, are considered rising stars on the new-music scene.
At a time when composers struggle to expand the musical appetite of audiences who expect Mozart and Beethoven, it's a rare opportunity for developing talents to hear their pieces performed in a subscription concert, and to get feedback from both the maestro of a top symphony orchestra and its musicians.
"You're giving me a huge challenge," Vänskä told Kati Agócs of Boston during their discussion of her score. "The tempo is too fast. You can use my comments as you like, but never do that again, please."
Later in the hall, the orchestra rehearsed Agócs' dense, bold, wide-ranging "Perpetual Summer," by turns discordantly suspenseful and richly majestic, complete with crashing cymbals and even a siren.
"It's great to have a major orchestra take a crack at it," she said. "And Osmo made some excellent points about the tempo."