Think back to civics class in the early years of your education. This is when most of us first learned about the fundamentals of American government: The Constitution, separation of powers, federalism and more. We were taught that while our system isn't perfect, it was constructed in a manner that diffuses power to protect against tyranny.
Despite the ideological factions that existed at our nation's founding, these ideas were something on which all could agree. History is replete with examples of tragedy when a single human wields too much power.
Now think about everything you witnessed your state government do over the last year, mostly by executive fiat: crushing lockdowns and economic restrictions that significantly hurt the average American's ability to earn a living and provide for their family.
Far from a forgotten civics lesson, millions of Americans learned firsthand how their government can completely upend their daily lives.
At the peak of state-ordered lockdowns in response to COVID-19, 316 million Americans across 42 states lived under a stay-at-home order. Businesses and places of worship were ordered closed. Millions lost their jobs and savings. Elective surgeries were canceled or delayed as thousands of cancer screenings and organ transplants went unperformed. All this, and we're barely scratching the surface of unintended consequences as a result of last year's pandemic policy.
Most rules we were told to follow were implemented by executive order under an emergency declaration. Few, if any, were subject to the deliberative scrutiny of our state legislatures. When courts were asked to intervene, many punted the issue back to legislatures, or in some cases, chief executives modified their rules in an attempt to nullify the pending litigation.
Perhaps you're wondering how a country built on individual liberty could fall so far from its founding ideals. How did our system of governance allow this to happen? Who watches the watchmen during an emergency?
As exhibited by the responses of many governors to the coronavirus pandemic, the truth is that the chief executive is too powerful in most states, specifically in emergency situations.