In response to Kelly Swanson's Aug. 29 commentary on her difficulty finding employment because of her age, I would like to relate my experiences as a personnel director of a major retailer in the southeastern U.S. I worked at this job for 40 years.
When I first began my job as an employment interviewer, I was told to not hire anyone over 40. This was in 1949 when there was no law against age discrimination. As I started hiring, I was impressed with the older applicants and on my own decided to ignore the age limit and test my judgment in believing in the reliability and experience qualities I saw in the older applicants. I followed up on each person I had hired. I found the older people were accepted by co-workers and in many cases became mentors. I continued the practice throughout my career and demonstrated that a mix of age groups was productive.
Swanson did not say if she had been interviewed by any employer. The interview was always very crucial in determining whether the applicant was right for the job. I did not usually employ anyone who complained about their previous employer. A willing attitude was something I always looked for in a candidate.
Barbara Franze Schoening, Minneapolis
• • •
I identify with all of Swanson's points to some extent: devastated by a layoff, depressed by rejection and numbed by the waste of time away from work. Remember when lack of experience was a detriment? Swanson and many of those commenting on her article at StarTribune.com point to misguided hiring managers and economic volatility, and there is justification for some of it, of course. Part of our society has started making a slow and fundamental change to employment. I'm speaking of the employee-ownership segment of the economy.
For people in Swanson's position, and some day my own, the option of joining other unattached employees to form an employee-owned co-op business ought to be available and approachable by networking and social media. Co-ops are only one option. Employee stock-ownership plans (ESOPs) have an enduring track record, particularly in the grocery field (Coburn's and Hy-Vee locally), the electrical service industry and others. Employee owners have bought their companies from previous owners, often families, are similar in organization to a pension plan and are useful for existing businesses desiring a smooth owner transition.
Co-ops may be an answer for people with skills and the ability to be creative in new ways. Swanson's skills in finance would be a necessary component to almost any venture you can think of. Is there risk? You bet. But after years of looking for work and being told that you're useless to society, wouldn't you like to prove them wrong?
Luke Maas, Edina
HILLARY CLINTON
On e-mails, she's getting a break that 'regular' people wouldn't
Hillary Clinton's deletion of thousands of her State Department e-mails while congressional inquiries and lawsuits have been ongoing is unprecedented for a Cabinet officer, but also something that has been addressed many times by American courts.