Barry Simonson's Oct. 15 commentary, "Enbridge's Line 3 is necessary," was deceptive.
He says that "demand for crude oil is expected to grow." But Enbridge's mainline system already far exceeds Minnesota's steady usage. If Simonson means global markets, he fails to consider growing world demand to end fossil fuel development and escalating global divestment. European Investment Bank President Werner Hoyer proposes to stop all fossil fuel lending by 2020. This trend continues as climate science demands leaving most remaining fossil fuels in the ground, lest we accelerate human extinction.
He says the oil "is already being shipped through Minnesota communities by truck and train." He fails to mention new technologies like BitCrude containers that transport semisolid bitumen (it's safe, nonflammable, floats on fresh and saltwater and is nontoxic to marine life).
Simonson claims "all of Minnesota stands to gain from this project." Some will gain financially. But we all will risk losing clean water.
"Looking long term," Simonson says, "each county crossed by the project will receive additional property tax revenue." Meanwhile, due to a Minnesota Tax Court ruling, Red Lake and Clearwater counties may owe Enbridge more in refunds than their entire annual budgets.
He claims that "thicker steel and state-of-the-art coatings will protect Minnesota's environment." Their pipes have been deteriorating on the ground for years. What studies have been done to show if this will adversely affect performance post-installation? Like the cracked pipes from improper shipping now necessitate a new Line 3, we may find deteriorated coatings are simply another failure for Enbridge.
Last, he says that "more than 14,000 Minnesotans … support … replacing Line 3." Minnesota's public comment process showed five times more (68,000) writing in opposition.
Jami Gaither, Alida, Minn.
ETHIOPIA
My country turns to democracy
As a member of the diasporan Ethiopian community in the Twin Cities, I appreciate the Star Tribune's recognition of the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to Abiy Ahmed, Ethiopia's prime minister ("A worthy Nobel for Ethiopia's Abiy," Oct. 12).