I read with interest the debate about pulling "To Kill a Mockingbird" (along with "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn") from the Duluth school curriculum ("In book debate, a painful turning of the page," Feb. 11). I am wondering about some of the real reasons for deciding to remove the book. If one of the reasons is to create a vanilla learning environment where "everyone gets a trophy," that is just wrong. Also, it is one of the great lessons learned in the book that growing up and finding out that the world is quite different from the world of inventing and playing games in our backyards — that the world can be a very cruel and unfair place.
There was also mention in the article that the book is "dated." I am wondering when lessons like empathy, hypocrisy and integrity have become dated. When standing up for what you believe in and doing what you know is the right thing even when everyone is telling you not to have become dated. I might argue that "To Kill a Mockingbird," with its life lessons, is even MORE relevant with what is happening in today's world.
I hope school districts and educators think long and hard before sweeping aside a masterpiece of American literature.
John Atkinson, Fridley
• • •
Good for Duluth for replacing "To Kill a Mockingbird" on its reading list. As author Shannon Gibney noted in the Feb. 11 article, it's a white-savior narrative. Atticus is the hero, and it's easy for white readers to imagine we'd do what Atticus did. More likely, we'd be the racist townspeople. If we want to talk about racism in the South, there are many other books to choose from. Let's consider some others in which the relatively wealthy white man isn't the hero of the story.
Kristin Boldon, Minneapolis
• • •
Regarding the decision by the Duluth School District to drop Mark Twain's "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" from its curriculum, I am still trying to digest the district's fine distinction between dropping and banning.
The book was a landmark in American literature, with Twain shifting from the mannered prose of his period (and of "The Adventures of Tom Sawyer") to language modeled on the speech of real everyday people. The novel includes ungrammatical phrases, dialect, and — yes — the "N-word." As is true of Twain's "Pudd'nHead Wilson," Twain's "Huck Finn" demonstrates that bigotry is ridiculous and inhumane — see, for example, slave Jim's speech to Huck about "trash."