The spirit of the rule is to keep a team from benefiting from its own mistake. But the football doesn't always bounce the way the rule intends.
That's why Aaron Green's forward fumble turned a broken play into a first down that broke the spirit of the Gophers defense.
On fourth-and-1 from the Gophers 13 midway through the first quarter, Nebraska quarterback Taylor Martinez rolled left, then pitched to Green. The ball bounced off Green's fingers and rolled out of bounds at the 11, just ahead of the first-down marker.
The Gophers, trailing only 3-0 at the time, began celebrating their apparent squelching of a Nebraska drive. But the officials huddled, then awarded the Cornhuskers a first down.
"What we had was a backward pass. The running back never controlled the ball. Therefore, it continues to be a backward pass -- it was muffed, which is touching the ball but not controlling it," referee Todd Geerlings explained after the game. "Rule 72-4A, page 72 of the NCAA Rulebook, states: 'When a backwards pass goes out of bounds between the goal lines, the ball belongs to the passing team at the out-of-bounds spot.' "
The Gophers sideline went crazy, and coach Jerry Kill conferred with the officials for more than a minute. "I said, 'How can you reward a fumble?' He goes, 'You're right, Coach, but that's the rule,' " Kill said. "And he's right."
Still, it was a crushing blow to the Gophers defense, which had already held the Huskers to a field goal on their first possession. Nebraska reached the end zone two plays later, on a 10-yard pass from Martinez to Tyler Legate.
"We thought we had them stopped. That was a critical play, mentally," Kill said.