Dear Amy: In our family, we have two people at extremes: One is a staunch anti-masker and anti-vaxxer. The other is almost paranoid in her efforts to be safe.
We traditionally have family gatherings at our home for most holidays. The anti-vaxxer usually will scoff at any virus protection shown by anyone when there is a gathering. Meanwhile, the extremely cautious one refuses to come in our house if the anti-vaxxer has been there in the previous 24 hours.
Reasoning with either of them has been fruitless. My wife and I are considering splitting the gatherings, so the two extremes do not conflict. This is very sad and means diluting the festivities we enjoy so much. We are hoping you have some suggestions.
Amy says: These two polar opposites have something major in common: Neither seems to be applying common sense to this challenge.
You have taken this on as a problem you hope to solve, in order to provide a homespun holiday experience for everyone.
You've done your own risk assessment and obviously don't believe that having unvaccinated people in your home presents a risk to you and yours. It seems that the family member who doesn't feel safe is inspiring you to dilute your celebration.
I think you should host your holiday meal (if you still want to) and let the usual parties know the time and place. Let them decide whether to attend.
If your more risk-averse relative doesn't feel safe in your home and is willing to see only vaccinated family members, then could they host their own gathering on another day in an atmosphere where they feel safe?