On Books Logo

Blog

On Books

Laurie Hertzel is senior editor for books at the Star Tribune, where she has worked since 1996.

UM Press pulls copies of "Sky Blue Water," postpones launch party

"Sky Blue Water" will be recalled by the University of MInnesota Press, and corrected books will be available in September.

"Sky Blue Water" will be recalled by the University of Minnesota Press, and corrected books will be available in September.

"Sky Blue Water," a collection of short stories by Minnesota writers edited by Jay Peterson and Collette A. Morgan, was set to have its launch party on Sept. 14.

Peterson, Morgan, and most of the young-adult writers who contributed to the anthology planned to be at the launch--National Book Award-winning writer William Alexander, John Coy, Pete Hautman, Shannon Gibney, Anika Fajardo, and many others. A portion of the proceeds from the sale of the book was intended for Mid-Continent Oceanographic Institute, a Twin Cities organization that offers free tutoring and writing assistance for students.

But now the Press has announced it is pulling the published books from bookstores and postponing the launch party. The problem lies in one paragraph in the book's foreword. The foreword was written by Kevin Kling, and the error was introduced in the editing process, said Emily Hamilton, assistant director of marketing.

The paragraph states: "Some believe that the Vikings navigated from the Atlantic Ocean to Minnesota more than a hundred years before Christopher Columbus discovered the Americas."

It was writer Shannon Gibney, whose short story, "Lone Star," is included in the anthology, who noticed the paragraph and called it to the Press's attention. In an e-mail, Gibney wrote, "Was there a reason why Kling and you all chose to present the Columbus encounter in this way? After all, this 'discovery' narrative has been effectively unhinged and reevaluated many times through the years by all kinds of historians, and I hate to see it reproduced in what bills itself as a progressive and inclusive new anthology of writing for children."

The Press did not disagree, nor did one of the two editors Gibney heard back from. On Facebook, Gibney posted the response from one of the editors (though did not say which one). " I, along with the writer and the team at [the] Press, wholeheartedly agree that this passage is entirely out of line with the spirit of the book, the mission of [the Mid-Continent Oceanographic Institute], and the press’s long history of publishing books about the people, history, and landscape of MN," the response read. "Please know that we’ve been working since you wrote to address the matter swiftly."

The Press, Hamilton said in an e-mail to the Star Tribune, "deeply regrets the unintended and incorrect meaning of this phrase. This error is out of step with the spirit of inclusiveness the team on this volume is committed to and worked to achieve in the development of the book."

Hamilton said the Press printed 4,000 copies of the book at a cost of about $4,000.

Corrected books are expected to be available by late September, and the launch party will be rescheduled.

"In addition to the recall and reprint, we are going to examine how this error got by the editorial safeguards we have in place to prevent such inaccuracies from making their way into our published books," Hamilton said.

"At the U of MN Press we take these matters seriously. 'Sky Blue Water' is not only an entertaining book, filled with terrific stories, but it is a powerful educational tool and a diverse reflection of young people's lives in Minnesota. We are proud to publish it and believe this action will only strengthen the book as a whole. It's an important book and we want to get it right."  

You have until Halloween to send us your manuscript

 

Start typing!

Start typing!

 

This summer isn't even over and yet here we are, searching for next summer's novel to be serialized in the pages of the Star Tribune.

The first four--Mary Logue's "Giving Up the Ghost"; Cary Griffith's "Savage Minnesota"; Megan Marsnik's "Under Ground"; and this summer's "Stone Lake" by Richard Horberg--have been so much fun, each completely diffrent from the next. (A ghost story, a mystery, a historical novel, a small-town journey.)

Readers followed along in print each day, caught up online, or purchased the e-book for $3.99.

So now we are looking for the next one. Maybe yours?

Manuscripts must be original and unpublished (either in print or digitally). Minnesota settings and authors are preferred but not mandatory--anyone can submit.

Do not send the whole book. (This is important.) Just send the first chapter (e-mail only, no hard copies) to books@startribune.com

If we love it, we'll ask for more.

Deadline is Oct. 31.

I can't wait to see what you send!

Event Calendar
  • Today
  • Thu
  • Fri
  • Sat
  • Sun

No Events Available.

Movies