TWIN032007

Home | Sports | Twins

Twins Insider: Being likable not enough of a reason to keep Silva

The manager and pitching coach are rooting for the veteran, but they shouldn't hand him a job unless he pitches better.

By La Velle E. Neal III

Last update: April 24, 2007 - 5:27 PM

TWINS SPRING TRAINING

Up next: 6:05 tonight vs. Boston

Fort Myers, Fla. • FSN • 1500-AM

More from Twins

FORT MYERS, FLA. - Twins righthander Carlos Silva dressed up as club mascot T.C. Bear last week and drew laughs and applause as he pulled off skit after skit with teammates before a game. It's one of many things Silva has done in recent years to keep a generally loose team loose.

"We like Carlos," Twins manager Ron Gardenhire said. "We like him a lot."

Liking someone, however, is not enough of a reason to give him a spot in a rotation when he isn't pitching well.

Silva has a 7.62 ERA in four spring outings. He's not throwing his sinking fastball well. His other pitches need work. And after losing his spot in the rotation briefly last season (and finishing 11-15 with a 5.94 ERA), Silva could be in line for similar treatment if he doesn't pull things together. And this time, a removal could last much longer than three weeks, which was how long he was out of the rotation last year.

On Sunday, Gardenhire strongly hinted that Silva is not on firm ground.

"We want him to be in our rotation desperately," Gardenhire said. "We think we need him. Nothing is a lock. He knows that. He has to go out and pitch."

It seems unlikely any pitcher has attracted the attention Silva has in workouts. On March 3, when pitching coach Rick Anderson was on a road trip, minor league pitching coordinator Rick Knapp, Class AAA Rochester pitching coach Stu Cliburn and Johan Santana offered encouragement while Silva threw in the bullpen. Santana has watched several of Silva's sessions during camp.

Instead of being on the bench Sunday for a game against Pittsburgh, Gardenhire and Anderson were on a back field watching Silva face minor leaguers while trying to fine-tune his pitches.

"His ball was moving and sinking," Gardenhire said. "He changed his arm angle a little bit and really had the ball diving. Had a great changeup. His slider still is not exactly what he wants to see, but I thought his ball was sinking really good. He got a ton of ground balls."

Silva still gave up three runs in four innings against Class AA New Britain, including an opposite-field homer.

"Seems like every mistake he makes -- even [Sunday when] he got one up -- they hit it," Gardenhire said. "It's a matter of him keeping that arm slot and making the ball move."

When asked what Silva's second-best pitch is, Gardenhire said the changeup -- not the slider, not the slider-curve hybrid Silva had when he came to the Twins as part of the Eric Milton trade in 2003. Instead, it is the changeup -- a pitch he started throwing in September of last season.

Does that make Silva a two-pitch pitcher, a one-pitch pitcher (considering he's still trying to harness his sinker) or a 1½-pitch pitcher?

It's obvious the Twins, who picked up Silva's $4.35 million option during the offseason, are pulling for him. And indications are that Silva will open the season in the rotation along with Santana, Ramon Ortiz, Sidney Ponson and Boof Bonser.

But Silva has little room for error because several prospects have auditioned impressively this spring. If this was a movie, it could be called "Rotation Crashers."

Bonser, a righthander, wasn't considered a lock coming into camp but has made a statement with his 2.25 ERA. He's likely the fifth starter.

Lefthander Glen Perkins has a new sinker and a 2.00 ERA. If he is not in the rotation now, he is likely first in line if something happens.

Don't misread that as an indictment of righthander Matt Garza (1.50 ERA in camp). The Twins rave about his talent, though some feel he needs polish. But he's close.

Righthander Kevin Slowey (3.38 ERA in camp) has joined the "nearly ready" wave because of his excellent control and willingness to mix four pitches.

Righthander Scott Baker (9.64 ERA in five outings) is out of the picture and needs a big year in the minors.

Rotation spots could change over the final 12 games of spring training, based on who sails and who fails as the games turn more serious. But it's clear that Silva not only has to finish camp strong, he also has to start the season strong or he could get run over by the future -- well-liked or not.

La Velle E. Neal III lneal@startribune.com

Comment on this story | Read all 0 comments | Hide reader comments

Carl Pohlad's funeral

Carl Pohlad earned billions, but his son said he cared little about the trappings of wealth.

Snow doesn't dampen opening day spirit

Twins fans and players alike shrugged off the snow for opening day and heralded the arrival of the baseball season.

Tour Target Field

Minnesota Twins President David St. Peter gives a walking tour of Target Field.

Twins players swap jerseys for aprons

Minnesota Twins players worked as waiters Sunday night to raise money for the Boys and Girls Club.

Animation of the ballpark construction process

Animation created by Mortenson Construction showing the process of building the new Twins stadium.

Time lapse of Twins stadium

On June 26, the Twins released a one-minute time lapse movie of how the construction has progressed over the past year.

Twins video player card: Mike Redmond

Twins catcher Mike Redmond talks about his hopes for the season and how things are going this spring. Final of nine in a series leading up to Opening Day.

Twins video player card: Boof Bonser

Twins pitcher Boof Bonser talks about his hopes for the season and how things are going this spring. Eighth of nine in a series leading up to Opening Day.

Twins video player card: Nick Punto

Twins infielder Nick Punto talks about his hopes for the season and how things are going this spring. Sixth of nine in a series leading up to Opening Day.

Twins video player card: Justin Morneau

Twins first baseman Justin Morneau talks about his hopes for the season and how things are going this spring. Fifth of nine in a series leading up to Opening Day.

Twins video player card: Brendan Harris

Twins second baseman Brendan Harris talks about his hopes for the season and how things are going this spring. Fourth of nine in a series leading up to Opening Day.

Twins video player card: Adam Everett

Twins shortstop Adam Everett talks about his hopes for the season and how things are going this spring. Third of nine in a series leading up to Opening Day.

Twins video player card: Mike Lamb

Twins third baseman Mike Lamb talks about his hopes for the season and how things are going this spring. Second of nine in a series leading up to Opening Day.

Twins video player card: Joe Mauer

Twins catcher Joe Mauer talks about his hopes for the season and how things are going this spring. First of nine in a series leading up to Opening Day.

Training camp: The battle for second base

Twins coach Ron Gardenhire is looking for Nick Punto to improve offensively and for Brendan Harris to be patient at the plate, but the competition for second base is close.

5-7-5: Twins are poets, don't 'cha know it?

Assorted Minnesota Twins read reader-submitted Haiku with flair ... or not.

Cuddyer is ready to lead the Twins

Michael Cuddyer says he's probably a natural fit to lead the team since he's got the most experience with the organization.

Who's going to make Twins roster?

Baseball writers La Velle E. Neal III and Joe Christensen think Wednesday's lineup against Boston features the A-listers or as close as it can be given the tough competition.