A congressional staff report this month on the Paycheck Protection Program didn't have much good to say about the Treasury Department's execution of it. The program failed to get enough money to the most vulnerable business owners, the report said. And while the report may have been partisan, there's clearly something to this.
The businesses most left out from the forgivable loans in the program were the true mom-and-pops, including many owned by Black entrepreneurs, that are not as well connected to commercial bankers.
A key contention by the congressional committee is not only that banks took care of their big customers first, they were directed to do so by the Treasury Department.
Fortune 500 firms are too big to get these forgivable loans, of course, but most of them seem to be weathering the pandemic year just fine. It's been a terrible year for many small businesses, especially those trying to deliver face-to-face services while a deadly disease spreads.
Minnesota has 20% fewer small businesses open than it did early in the year, as of the late September update by economists at a data site called Opportunity Insights.
What seemed to really help in getting a PPP loan quickly was being a good customer of a bank. Having an account at the bank wasn't likely enough.
Minnesota was highlighted as one of the bright spots for disseminating PPP loans, particularly early on when it looked like there wouldn't be enough money to go around.
That's because Minnesota has a healthy number of community banks that are far more likely to have staffers who really know their small-business customers.