Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz's State of the State to be streamed online Sunday
This article is updated multiple times a day and is available for free to non-subscribers as a public service. Please consider subscribing to the Star Tribune.
As the pandemic spreads, we've asked readers what they most want to know. Our reporters have talked to the experts and answered some of the most pressing and popular questions. For daily updates, sign up for our newsletter.
- Memo: Some in United States may not get stimulus checks until August.
- Hospitalizations rise as Minnesota announces one more death, 53 new confirmed cases of COVID-19. Seventy-five people are hospitalized today, with 38 requiring intensive care.
- FDA approves first coronavirus antibody test in the United States.
- Michaels, Jo-Ann stores open despite Minnesota clarifying that arts, crafts stores are included in stay-at-home order.
- Dairy farmers begin to flush away milk due to coronavirus.
- A ventilator stockpile, with one hitch: Thousands do not work. A contract issue meant that firm in Minneapolis did not begin its work until late January.
- Just when Minnesotans are cleaning house, there's hardly anywhere to take stuff.
- Police: Man coughs on Moorhead grocery worker, blames minorities for virus.
- More than 6.6 million Americans applied for unemployment benefits last week — doubling a record high set just one week earlier.
- After criticism, University of Minnesota president says she will propose new "fee refund" for students.
- Gov. Tim Walz calls off Governor's Fishing Opener; season still set to open as scheduled.
- With 5 more COVID-19 deaths, Minnesota officials upset by lack of testing supplies. The state now has 689 documented cases and 17 deaths.
- Minnesota health officials continue to conceal names of senior care facilities with coronavirus.
- Here's why Minnesota doesn't have enough hospital beds right now, writes columnist Lee Schafer.
- Grammy-winning artist Lizzo bought lunch this week for teams of emergency room workers in Minnesota and around the U.S., much to their delight.
- Abbott's 5-minute test among Minnesota products on front lines of virus fight.
- Gas prices slip below $1 a gallon at some Minnesota gas stations.
- One rural Minnesota county becomes an unlikely coronavirus hotbed.
- Out of toilet paper? We've got some solutions and some precautions.
- Two more die of COVID-19 as Minnesota announces 53 more cases, bringing the state's documented total to 629. Health officials reported 39 outbreaks in group living facilities.
How many cases are there in Minnesota?
Minnesota has documented 742 cases of COVID-19, with 53 new cases reported Wednesday, along with one more death. State officials say that these numbers are based on limited testing and are likely an undercount. Seventy-five patients are currently hospitalized, with 38 requiring intensive care. Eighteen people in Minnesota have died of COVID-19. The map below shows a county-by-county breakdown, which is updated as information becomes available. (It may lag behind news reports due to the release of incomplete information.) The state is posting some updates online and has a phone hotline: 651-201-3920.
How many cases are there in the world? The United States?
Around the world, there have been more than 1,000,000 confirmed cases and more than 51,000 deaths. The United States has more than 234,000 cases in all 50 states, with more than 92,300 cases in New York. The U.S. death toll climbed to more than 5,700 this week, with 2,468 dead in New York and more than 500 in New Jersey. Michigan and Louisiana have more than 300 deaths each.
The New York Times is tracking U.S. cases, including a state-by-state breakdown of totals and how the illnesses were contracted. Johns Hopkins University has a real-time interactive dashboard following the spread of COVID-19 across the U.S. and the world.
Does the drug chloroquine help prevent COVID-19?
UPDATE: The Food and Drug Administration has given emergency use approval to a Trump administration plan to distribute millions of doses of anti-malarial drugs to hospitals across the country, saying it is worth the risk of trying unproven treatments to slow the progression of the disease caused by the novel coronavirus in seriously ill patientss.
The drugs known chemically as hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine have been available for decades to treat the mosquito-borne illness malaria. Technically, doctors can already prescribe it to patients with COVID-19, a practice known as off-label prescribing.
Drug trials typically require hundreds or thousands of patients and, even when accelerated, take weeks or months to complete. While chloroquine has shown promise in preliminary laboratory studies, some experts are skeptical it will prove effective in human testing.
Health experts warn the drugs’ well-known side effects could become commonplace with wide use. Patients with existing heart problems or taking certain drugs, such as anti-depressants that affect heart rhythm, are at risk of a fatal episode.
The drugs are for treatment in patients already infected. They do not prevent the illness or the spread of the virus. One study is testing chloroquine to try to protect health care workers at highest risk of infection, because a vaccine is likely a year or more away.
What is "flattening the curve" and how does social distancing help?
“Flattening the curve” is an expression used to explain how slowing the exponential growth in a disease’s spread can allow a country’s health system to better cope with the surge in cases so that it isn’t overwhelmed.
While the novel coronavirus pandemic might eventually infect a majority of people in the United States, the speed at which the outbreak spreads makes a huge difference in health outcomes. What epidemiologists fear is that the U.S. health system would become overwhelmed by a sudden surge that requires more people to be hospitalized than can be handled, both from a personnel and equipment standpoint. In a scenario of uncontrolled growth, more people would die simply because there might not be enough doctors, nurses, hospital beds or ventilators for people who need them.
“If you look at the curves of outbreaks, they go big peaks, and then come down. What we need to do is flatten that down,” said Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases.
Flattening the curve means that the social distancing measures being deployed in places like Italy and South Korea and now in the United States aren’t so much about preventing illness but rather slowing down the rate at which people get sick, according to Vox.
Without any measures to slow it down, COVID-19 will spread exponentially for months. An interactive simulation by the Washington Post shows how the spread can be slowed by use of “social distancing,” avoiding public spaces and large group gatherings that can increase the rapid spread of COVID-19.
What's the best way to prepare?
COVID-19 is a respiratory disease, much like influenza, and while there’s not a vaccine for it, there are ways to cope. The precautions used to fight influenza are the same ones that people should be using to stave off coronavirus and other respiratory diseases, said Timothy Brewer, a professor of epidemiology and medicine at UCLA’s Fielding School of Public Health.
- Wash your hands regularly
- Cover your nose and mouth when you sneeze
- Stay home from work or school when you’re sick
- Drink lots of fluids
The CDC recommends washing with soap and water for at least 20 seconds after using the bathroom, before eating and after blowing your nose or sneezing. It also advises to avoid touching your eyes, nose and mouth and to frequently clean objects and surfaces you touch often.
Should I be wearing a mask?
UPDATE: For weeks, public health specialists and officials from the Centers for Disease Control have said that if you are not sick, there is no reason to wear a mask.
However, officials at the CDC are considering altering the official guidance to encourage people to take measures to cover their faces amid the coronavirus pandemic, according to a federal official who spoke on the condition of anonymity to the Washington Post this week.
Simple cloth masks that cover the mouth and nose can prevent virus transmission from such individuals when they are out buying groceries or seeking medical care, according to the memos obtained by Post.
There are specialized masks — known as N95 masks because they filter out 95% of airborne particles — that are more effective, but the masks are difficult to use without training and should be reserved for front-line health workers. Those masks must be fitted and tested to work properly. The same goes for exam gloves, which can get contaminated just like our hands. There’s no need for them if you’re washing your hands properly and often.
While surgical or home-made cloth masks do not provide the level of protection that N95 masks do, they would potentially lower the risk that the wearer, if infected, would transmit the virus to other people.
Is hand sanitizer effective against COVID-19?
Washing your hands with soap and water is the most effective way to protect yourself, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “But if soap and water are not available, using a hand sanitizer with at least 60% alcohol can help you avoid getting sick and spreading germs to others,” the agency says on its website. Sanitizers do not eliminate all types of germs and they are less effective if your hands are visibly dirty or greasy.
“It is very important when you use hand sanitizer that you use an adequate amount and you cover all of the surfaces of your hands,” said Dr. Alison Peterson, vice president of medical affairs at Allina Health’s United Hospital in St. Paul. Also, let your hands dry before touching anything. Apart from cleaning your hands, remember not to touch your face, something that is often easier said than done.
What happens if workers at power plants, water treatment facilities, grocers, etc., get sick?
State officials are working with businesses to encourage them to prepare now for the eventuality that they could be short-handed in a pandemic outbreak. “In particular with essential services and infrastructure, identify what are your core activities and make sure that you have cross-trained so that everything doesn’t rely on one person that pushes that one button,” said Kris Ehresmann, director of infectious disease for the Minnesota Health Department.
The general public should also prepare in case some retail locations are closed or have limited hours. “We want people to start to gradually prepare to have an adequate supply of nonperishable food items at home,” she said. That would be especially helpful if you or your family became sick and could not leave home. At the same time, authorities discourage panic buying. “We certainly don’t want people to think that we are asking them to plan for Armageddon.”
TESTING, HEALTH CARE
Should I get tested for COVID-19?
Last week, Minnesota's public health lab announced it is restricting criteria for COVID-19 testing after a surge of testing activity that taxed its supply of kits and chemical reagents needed to confirm the presence of the coronavirus that causes the illness. The Minnesota Department of Health announced the change after a two-day surge in testing.
Testing for now will be restricted to hospitalized patients, health care workers, residents of long-term care facilities, and others at highest risk for spreading the virus or suffering the worst complications from it. Testing capacity in Minnesota is expected to expand as private labs develop their own capacity to perform the test.
Like any medical test, there has to be a clinical reason to perform the procedure. In the case of COVID-19, someone must have symptoms of the disease like fever, coughing and shortness of breath. Travel to an area with active transmission of COVID-19 is also a factor, as well as close contact with someone who is sick or had travelled. The Minnesota Department of Health said it has asked doctors to test their patients for other respiratory illnesses before submitting a COVID-19 test. “At present we do not recommend testing for those that do not have symptoms,” said Dr. Mark Sannes, an infectious disease physician at Park Nicollet. It can take anywhere from two to 14 days for COVID-19 symptoms to develop and until they do the test won’t pick up signs of the disease. “It is more about making sure that you identify whether someone that has exposure develops disease or not,” said Sannes. “Testing them early on in their incubation period doesn't help settle that question.” Even those who have been asked to quarantine often will not be tested until they have symptoms.
The COVID-19 test, which involves a nose or a throat swab, can detect the disease but it cannot tell doctors how severe the case will become.
“We want people to keep in mind that we have the capacity to test but we want to make sure that those tests are used in the best way possible,” said MDH infectious disease director Kris Ehresmann. “At the state and national level we don't have unlimited supplies. We want to focus on individuals who are in a high risk situation.”
If someone gets sick, when should I suspect COVID-19?
COVID-19 arrived during peak cold and flu season, and many of the symptoms are the same: fever, cough and sneezing. So based on symptoms alone, it is hard to tell. But this new coronavirus has been known to severely impact the lungs. When we hear someone has shortness of breath, we will have more concern and they will need to be seen, said Dr. Jeff Dichter, a critical care physician at M Health Fairview.
Doctors say that dehydration from vomiting or diarrhea, a severe headache and progressively worsening symptoms also are warning signs. If you have a chronic medical condition that makes you more susceptible to complications from any type of viral infection, such as pneumonia, it is important to seek medical care. One suggestion is to call your clinic to get advice on how to proceed. Many clinics have a nurse who will triage cases, and you will most likely be asked about travel history and symptoms. If the clinic suggests that you see a doctor, staff might meet you at the front door and provide you with a mask to help prevent infecting others.
If COVID-19 does take hold in Minnesota, the health care system is likely to prioritize care for those who are the sickest. The health care system is extremely full right now and always runs close to capacity, said Dr. John Hick, emergency physician and medical director for emergency preparedness at Hennepin Healthcare. Be prepared for longer waits and potentially non-traditional approaches to care. The focus of the health care system will be on taking care of those with severe disease that may require prolonged and intensive care.
Does Minnesota have hospital bed capacity to handle cases that would require acute care in the event of an outbreak?
The Minnesota Hospital Association (MHA) says it is making plans for a possible surge of COVID-19 patients, and is anticipating that 15% of them will need hospital care and 5% will need intensive care. As it stands, the system is already seeing high demand, with more than 95% of beds occupied on one or more days in the Twin Cities metro area in recent weeks, said Dr. Rahul Koranne, MHA chief executive.
Based on its planning, the hospital group has said there could be a need for more intensive care beds, ventilators, masks and other protective equipment for health care workers, as well as for staffing, phone banks to help triage patients, and training on COVID-19. “If there was a challenge to our capacity, hospitals would have to look at constructing additional space for those,” said Wendy Burt, MHA spokeswoman. Hospitals and health care systems are working with the Minnesota Health Department to coordinate information about resources.
What is a novel coronavirus?
A novel coronavirus is a new coronavirus that has not been previously identified. Coronaviruses are a large family of viruses. According to the CDC, the virus causing this outbreak is not the same as the coronaviruses that commonly circulate and cause mild illness, such as the common cold. Some coronaviruses cause illnesses in people; others cause viruses in animals such as cattle, camels and bats. Rarely, animal coronaviruses can spread to people. This happened with SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV. The virus that causes COVID-19 likely also originated in an animal and spread to humans, according to the CDC.
Will warm weather stop the outbreak of COVID-19?
The Centers for Disease Control says that it is not yet known whether weather and temperature impact the spread of COVID-19. Some other viruses, like the common cold and flu, spread more during cold weather months but that does not mean it is impossible to become sick with these viruses during warm weather.
Communities in warmer places appear to have a comparative advantage in slowing the transmission of coronavirus infections, according to an early analysis by scientists at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
The New York Times published news of the MIT study along with two others that have drawn similar conclusions. But none of the studies have been peer-reviewed by other scientists, and the MIT study's author acknowledged that factors such as travel restrictions, social distancing measures, variations in the availability of tests and hospital burdens might have affected the number of cases in different countries.
Can the coronavirus live on surfaces outside the body, for example in retail or food settings?
The most common method of catching COVID-19 illness is by inhaling respiratory droplets created when an infected person sneezes or coughs, especially through close contact over a sustained time period. “We know that your highest risk is in being close contact with another person who is in their acute phase of infection,” said Dr. Alison Peterson of Allina Health's United Hospital. “If a [sick] person coughs into your face that is high risk.” However, it is possible that the novel coronavirus could be on surfaces, such as door handles, elevator buttons and other things that get touched frequently. That is why health officials are emphasizing the importance of washing your hands and not touching your face.
“It may be possible that a person can get COVID-19 by touching a surface or object that has the virus on it and then touching their own mouth, nose, or possibly their eyes, but this is not thought to be the main way the virus spreads,” according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control.
Ultimately, researchers can’t prove that surfaces are totally safe, which is why they ask people to take some precautions for protection from COVID-19 as well as other diseases such as influenza and the common cold. The risk is even lower for packages that are shipped weeks ago or from long distances. “In general, because of poor survivability of these coronaviruses on surfaces, there is likely very low risk of spread from products or packaging that are shipped over a period of days or weeks,” according to the CDC. It is good practice to clean surfaces at home using products containing bleach or 70% alcohol. “Wipe down commonly touched surfaces. Use appropriate precautions in your home that would do with the common respiratory illnesses,” said Peterson. The Environmental Protection Agency has guidelines for which products to use against SARS-CoV-2.
COVID-19 and other coronaviruses can live on surfaces for a few hours or up to several days, according to the World Health Organization, depending on the type of surface and the temperature and humidity. One recent study, which has not yet been reviewed by other scientists, found the novel coronavirus was viable up on copper up to 4 hour, up to 24 hours on cardboard and two to three days on plastic and stainless steel.
If you are diagnosed with the virus and recover, are you immune?
Because COVID-19 is still a relatively new human infection, researchers are still learning more about it. “Based on more common circulating coronaviruses, there is some evidence that people can be infected more than once over subsequent years,” said Dr. Susan Kline at M Health Fairview. “But I don’t think we know yet with this COVID-19." In the 2003 SARS outbreak, which was also caused by a type of coronavirus, there was evidence that the virus was still present in respiratory secretions, blood, urine and tissue “going into three weeks of illness, sometimes even longer among people who are more seriously ill.”
Does the pneumonia vaccination help fend off pneumonia-like symptoms with coronavirus?
While the elderly or those susceptible to pneumonia are encouraged to get that vaccine, it won’t protect you against the viral pneumonia that is associated with COVID-19. “The pneumonia vaccine just protects against pneumococcal pneumonia,” which is a bacterial infection, said Dr. Susan Kline, infection prevention medical director for M Health Fairview. “But it can’t protect against all pneumonia and it does not protect against viral pneumonias.”
TRAVEL, GETTING AROUND
What travel restrictions are in place?
Last week, Gov. Tim Walz issued an executive order directing Minnesotans to stay in their homes unless absolutely necessary, for at least two weeks beginning at midnight March 27 through at least April 10. “What our objective is now is to move the infection rate out, slow it down and buy time,” the governor said, adding that “the place we cannot go to is when someone cannot get that ICU care.”
In the United States, President Trump has extended federal social distancing guidelines through April 30. Many states and local governments have stiffer controls in place on mobility and gatherings. The federal guidelines recommend against group gatherings larger than 10 and urge older people and anyone with existing health problems to stay home. People are urged to work at home when possible and avoid restaurants, bars, non-essential travel and shopping trips.
Earlier, the U.S. State Department issued a Level 4 "Do Not Travel" alert and advised U.S. citizens to avoid all international travel due to the global impact of COVID19. The broad warning states: "If you choose to travel internationally, your travel plans may be severely disrupted, and you may be forced to remain outside of the United States for an indefinite timeframe." In countries where commercial departure options remain available, U.S. citizens who live in the US should arrange for immediate return. The State Departmen says it has also suspended routine visa service in most countries.
In addition, many countries have introduced mandatory quarantines and travel restrictions, in some cases stranding U.S. citizens, including Minnesotans, who were living or traveling abroad.
The CDC is advising older adults and people with severe medical conditions such as heart, lung or kidney disease to “stay home as much as possible” and avoid crowds. It urges those people to “take actions to reduce your risk of exposure,” but it doesn’t specifically address flying.
The federal government said it is postponing the deadline for obtaining REAL ID-compliant identification cards because of the coronavirus. Travelers would have been required to present REAL ID cards to board U.S. flights starting on Oct. 1. The new deadline has not yet been announced.
The CDC assesses the coronavirus risk in countries worldwide.
What is the status of Metro Transit service?
Metro Transit has curtailed service on buses and light-rail trains by 40% as the agency responds to the pandemic, which has led to a steep drop in ridership.
Service will operate on schedules that are often used on days after major holidays such as Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year's Day, said spokesman Howie Padilla.
Metro Transit says buses, trains and facilities are being regularly disinfected. Customer service information is available at 612-373-3333 between 6:30 a.m. and 9 p.m. weekdays and 8 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. on weekends. Riders are encouraged to use the Show My Bus feature on mobile or desktop websites.
Metro Transit also encourages its customers to help prevent the spread of infection by: covering your cough, washing your hands, avoiding touching your face and staying home when you are sick.
“Metro Transit maintains contingency plans for all types of emergencies, including pandemics,” said Metropolitan Council spokeswoman Terri Dresen.
MORTALITY RATES, RISK FACTORS
What is the mortality rate compared with influenza? What segment of the population is most at risk?
UPDATE: A new report from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention examined more than 7,000 U.S. cases of COVID-19 and reaffirmed the risks to the sick and elderly. People with at least one underlying condition, such as diabetes, represented 37% of overall COVID-19 patients, but 78% of those needing intensive hospital care. Just being older than 65 was a risk factor for needing intensive care.
According to the U's Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy, a team from the United Kingdom published a new case-fatality rate estimate of 1.4%, based on all available data on deaths in and outside of China.
COVID-19 is more fatal than the seasonal flu, but not as deadly as some other viruses. “We’ve certainly seen infectious diseases in fairly recent memory that are much more lethal than COVID-19 at this point,” said Minnesota Health Commissioner Jan Malcolm.
Ebola, which primarily has affected African countries, had a fatality rate of 50%. COVID-19 is the name of the illness caused by exposure to the SARS-CoV-2 virus. Recent estimates have suggested a fatality rate between 1.4% and 3.4%. The flu’s death rate is about 0.1%. By comparison, two other coronavirus-type outbreaks were more fatal: 10% for the 2003 SARS outbreak, which also started in China, and 30% for the 2012 MERS outbreak, which was confined to the Arabian Peninsula.
The COVID-19 fatality rate was determined by a study of nearly 45,000 patients conducted by China’s disease control agency. That number is likely to change as other studies are conducted and more is known is about the number of mild cases. However, like the flu, the elderly and those with chronic health conditions that affect their ability to fight off infection have higher mortality rates. According to the Chinese study, 81% of cases were mild, while 14% had more severe infections and 5% needed intensive hospital care, a group that saw higher death rates. “When the disease is severe, it can be quite severe,” Malcolm said.
The CDC offers guidance to those who are at risk for serious illness with COVID-19, including older adults and those with heart disease, diabetes or lung disease. In addition, if you have another chronic health problem, cancer or are immune-compromised, doctors suggest extra caution.
Not everyone with the virus will exhibit symptoms, and about 80 percent of people with the virus do not end up needing hospitalization, health experts say.
Are residents of large buildings at risk because of the ventilation systems?
It is unclear if COVID-19 can be spread through residential or office ventilation systems. “We know that your highest risk is in being close contact with another person who is in their acute phase of infection,” said Dr. Alison Peterson at Allina’s United Hospital. The water droplets formed when an infected person coughs or sneezes are thought to be the main method of transmission.
“We haven’t heard of any case that has come from ventilation,” she said. Some viruses, such as measles, float in the air for a while and have been documented to travel through ventilation systems. Most notably, in 1991 the measles virus was passed through the Metrodome’s ventilation system, infecting 16 people at a Special Olympics event. The COVID-19 virus is thought to be heavier and eventually will sink to the ground.
In a hospital, as a precautionary measure, most people who are seriously ill with a viral infection are placed in a hospital room with specialized ventilation equipment that will direct the air outside the building and not circulate it internally.
ASK A QUESTION
Do you have coronavirus questions?
Janet Moore contributed to this report. This article also includes information from the Washington Post and Associated Press.