Economist: Some high-tech solutions fail with fight against Ebola in West Africa

New, special gear is expensive, which can make it unsuitable for poorer West African nations.

March 9, 2015 at 11:19PM
Health care workers inside a USAID, funded Ebola clinic with their Ebola virus protective gear in Monrovia, Liberia, Friday, Jan. 30, 2015. The World Health Organization says officials are now focused on ending the biggest-ever Ebola outbreak rather than just slowing the virusí spread. In an update published Thursday, Jan. 29, 2015, the U.N. health agency said the three most affected countries _ Guinea, Sierra Leone and Liberia _ reported fewer than 100 cases in the past week, for the first
Health care workers inside a USAID-funded Ebola clinic in Liberia wearing protective gear. Some of the best protective gear or technology is not available to African countries because of high costs or other conditions. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

An Ebola patient racked with acute symptoms may shed nearly three gallons a day of highly infectious blood and other body fluids, feces and decomposing tissue. It makes caring for patients suffering from this dreadful disease difficult and dangerous.

As in all Ebola episodes, preventing infection in West Africa during what has been the worst outbreak in history has placed a lot of effort on looking after those dealing with the victims. New high-tech equipment is now available for use by health care workers, but in some countries it may be inappropriate.

The Ebola virus is spread by direct contact, which can be through the tiniest piece of broken skin or via mucous membranes. Protective equipment is needed. But when Nichodemus Gebe, head of biomedical engineering at Ghana's Ministry of Health, started looking for specialist gear he was unable to find any easily transportable treatment units able to contain the virus. Last July, he asked Odulair, a company in Cheyenne, Wyo., if it could help. The firm makes mobile medical clinics.

Two months later Odulair put a modular Ebola-isolation unit on the market. The unit maintains a differential air pressure between rooms to help prevent the virus from spreading; although not an airborne disease, it can attach to particles which drift in the air. A higher pressure is maintained in areas reserved for medical staff and those awaiting diagnosis. The air in each room is purified up to 36 times an hour with filters that trap almost all particles larger than a third of a micron, or three millionths of a meter, which is smaller than the Ebola virus. Air is also zapped with germ-killing ultraviolet light.

The doors in the unit can open automatically, allowing a "telepresence" robot to patrol. It displays live video of a doctor or nurse, allowing them to speak to a patient. The RP-VITA, as the robot is called, greatly reduces the number of times staff must put on protective suits and step inside, says Anita Chambers, Odulair's boss.

But only two Odulair isolation units have been sold. One unit was delivered to a contractor working for America's Department of Homeland Security and the other will soon be sent to Trinidad and Tobago. For poor countries, such equipment is unaffordable, says Gebe. An Odulair unit to house 10 confirmed and eight suspected patients costs about $900,000, robot not included. A Q-10 comes in at around $53,000 and a Xenex robot at some $100,000.

Nevertheless, some new technology is helping in West Africa, where the number of cases has fallen, but the disease is hanging on. The bible on stopping transmission in poor countries was for many years a 1998 report by the World Health Organization and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) entitled "Infection Control for Viral Haemorrhagic Fevers in the African Health Care Setting." It enshrined a "sort of lowest common denominator" realism based on what was widely available rather than most appropriate, says Armand Sprecher, a Doctors Without Borders epidemiologist. It helped to establish surgical garb as the thing to wear.

But clothing designed for operating rooms is not the best for, say, collecting corpses lying in infectious body fluids. Aprons and surgical gowns leave the wearer's back mostly unprotected so, when squatting to lift a body, material on their boots is likely to wet the cotton surgical scrubs on their buttocks and thighs. "That's an uncomfortable feeling," Sprecher says. He began working on Ebola outbreaks with MSF in 2000, several years before coveralls made with a DuPont synthetic fiber called Tyvek became widely available.

Tyvek is produced from high-density polyethylene fibers. These are not woven, as most fabrics are, but "flashspun" in a process that involves the evaporation of a solvent. Although tear-resistant and waterproof, Tyvek does allow air molecules under high pressure to pass through. This has now led to the wide adoption of a more impermeable laminated DuPont fabric called Tychem.

Coveralls made with Tychem, however, have a big drawback. The material restricts gas exchange enough to prevent evaporative cooling, so wearers in hot weather may quickly overheat, becoming confused or even suffering a heat stroke.

In the past decade latex gloves have largely been replaced by those made with nitrile, a synthetic rubber that better resists disintegrating in chlorine disinfectants. Goggles are increasingly designed with ventilation slits not placed on the top, lest sweat or rain wash contaminants into the eyes. And surgical masks are now more widely used because their cost has dropped some 75 percent in the past 15 years, says Juan Martínez Hernández, an epidemiologist and Ebola expert based in Madrid.

Surgical masks, however, lose effectiveness when soaked with sweat. More expensive "duckbill" designs that protrude from the face work better. MSF is field-testing a handful of respirators, which are powered by a battery pack.


Copyright 2013 The Economist Newspaper Limited, London. All Rights Reserved. Reprinted with permission.

A grave digger takes a break at the King Tom cemetery, where burials for all the city's deaths from Ebola are handled by teams in protective gear, in Freetown, Sierra Leone, Feb. 21, 2015. As epidemics taper off, it is common to find new complications in the effort to reach zero cases — in Sierra Leone, the trade between cities and remote fishing villages is one of the remaining vectors for the spread of the virus. (Bryan Denton/The New York Times)
A grave digger takes a break at the King Tom cemetery, where burials for all the city's deaths from Ebola are handled by teams in protective gear, in Freetown, Sierra Leone, Feb. 21, 2015. As epidemics taper off, it is common to find new complications in the effort to reach zero cases — in Sierra Leone, the trade between cities and remote fishing villages is one of the remaining vectors for the spread of the virus. (Bryan Denton/The New York Times) (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Ebola patient Beatrice Yardolo, celebrates with Ebola health workers as she leaves the Chinese Ebola treatment center were she was treated for Ebola virus infection on the outskirts of Monrovia, Liberia, Thursday, March 5, 2015. Liberia released its last Ebola patient, a 58-year old English teacher, from a treatment center in the capital on Thursday, beginning its countdown to being declared Ebola free. 'I am one of the happiest human beings today on earth because it was not easy going through t
Ebola patient Beatrice Yardolo celebrated her departure from a treatment center in Liberia, which released its last Ebola patient, a 58-year-old English teacher, on March 5. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

the Economist

More from Business

See More
card image
Fairview Health Services

The school is changing an elective course while still working with the Eden Prairie-based health care giant after students raised concerns.

This transmission electron microscope image shows SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, isolated from a patient in the U.S., emerging from the surface of cells cultured in the lab. (NIAID/TNS) ORG XMIT: 1659810
card image