70 years ago on D-Day, we forged a noble mission — one we still wrestle with today.
Seventy years later, it is what they managed to do here that is still so striking and inspiring. The greatest amphibious invasion in history — led by young American, British and Canadian paratroopers, soldiers, sailors and airmen — delivered Europe from Hitler’s evil and paved the road to the collapse of the Third Reich the next spring.
The D-Day landings are without question one of the most important achievements in U.S. history. For in landing on Normandy’s bloody beaches on June 6, 1944, these young men — to whom we still owe so much — went on to liberate all of Western Europe from Nazi tyranny. It took President Franklin Roosevelt years to marshal American strength so that he could say in his D-Day Prayer to the country: “Our sons, pride of our nation, this day have set upon a mighty endeavor … to set free a suffering humanity.”
As President Obama visits Normandy today with allied leaders, it will be one last chance to thank the aging veterans who stormed the beaches, pushed the Germans out of France, and then liberated Belgium, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, Denmark, Norway and Italy. It is also an opportunity to reflect on the real meaning of D-Day for 21st-century Americans.
We used our awesome power to restore freedom to millions of men and women. It was a noble mission paid for with the lives of many thousands of soldiers, many of whom still rest in the haunting, windswept Normandy countryside.
Today we face, mercifully, nothing as terrible as Roosevelt and Gen. Dwight Eisenhower’s struggle to defeat Hitler’s assault on human dignity. After D-Day, the United States launched a campaign for Europe’s peace and freedom through the defeat of Germany, the long decades of the Cold War, and the ultimate liberation of Eastern Europe with the collapse of communism.
Throughout the entire post-World-War-II era, the constant connective tissue in U.S. policy has been our commitment to human freedom in every part of the world. Every president has known that we can’t create those conditions on our own. We can’t resolve all of the world’s problems or join every fight for freedom. Having the wisdom and balance to decide when to intervene and when not to has become one of the most difficult and complex international challenges for global leaders.
But the United States still has the responsibility — when our allies are threatened or when the human carnage cannot be ignored — to defend other people’s freedom. Former President Bill Clinton has said that not intervening in Rwanda 20 years ago to stop genocide was the greatest mistake of his presidency. He later made the right decision to liberate the Muslim communities of Bosnia and Kosovo from Serb aggression.
This is the issue that Obama focused on in his much-anticipated West Point speech last week. After Iraq and Afghanistan, he was right to set the bar for military action high. We should not send our young men and women heedlessly into battle unless diplomacy has failed and it is absolutely necessary.
But the president focused almost exclusively at West Point on what we should not do in the world. At some point soon, he also must give us a clear sense of what we can and must do to fulfill the exceptional nature of America’s continued leadership in the world.
Another president, World War II veteran John F. Kennedy, intended to address America’s global responsibilities had he lived to give a speech that terrible afternoon in Dallas. He was to tell Americans they had to be “watchmen on the walls of world freedom.”
That is a true picture of the D-Day heroes we honor today. As their inheritors, it is how we must continue to think of ourselves today.
Nicholas Burns is a professor of the practice of diplomacy and international politics at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government.
The Opinion section is produced by the Editorial Department to foster discussion about key issues. The Editorial Board represents the institutional voice of the Star Tribune and operates independently of the newsroom.