Pitcher, Team 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th Points R.A. Dickey, Mets 27 5 209 Clayton Kershaw, Dodgers 2 11 10 1 6 96 Gio Gonzalez, Nationals 1 12 6 8 4 93 Johnny Cueto, Reds 1 4 10 10 2 75 Craig Kimbrel, Braves 1 5 5 9 41 Matt Cain, Giants 1 6 7 22 Kyle Lohse, Cardinals 2 2 6 Aroldis Chapman, Reds 1 1 Cole Hamels, Phillies 1 1 Below is a breakdown of the 32 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each team in the National League. Note that in some cases (*), when a city does not have enough eligible voters, a writer from another city will represent that chapter.
Name Affiliation Chapter 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th Tim Brown Yahoo Sports.com LA Kershaw Dickey Cueto Gonzalez Cain Bill Center U-T San Diego SD Dickey Gonzalez Cueto Kimbrel Chapman Ron Cook Pittsburgh Post Gazette PIT Dickey Cueto Gonzalez Kimbrel Kershaw Brian Costa Wall Street Journal NY Dickey Kershaw Gonzalez Cueto Kimbrel Jerry Crasnick ESPN.com PHI Kershaw Dickey Kimbrel Gonzalez Cain Guy Curtright Honorary ATL Dickey Gonzalez Kimbrel Cueto Kershaw Tony DeMarco Honorary AZ Dickey Kershaw Gonzalez Cain Kimbrel Steve Dilbeck Los Angeles Times LA Dickey Kershaw Gonzalez Cueto Cain Jack Etkin Honorary COL Dickey Kershaw Kimbrel Gonzalez Cueto John Fay Cincinnati Enquirer CIN Cueto Dickey Kershaw Lohse Gonzalez Derrick Goold St. Louis Post Dispatch STL Dickey Kershaw Cueto Lohse Kimbrel John Harper New York Daily News ATL* Dickey Kershaw Gonzalez Cain Kimbrel Chris Jenkins U-T San Diego SD Dickey Gonzalez Cueto Cain Kershaw Bob Klapisch Bergen (NJ) Record HOU* Dickey Gonzalez Kershaw Cueto Kimbrel Danny Knobler CBS Sports.com HOU* Dickey Gonzalez Kimbrel Cueto Kershaw Dejan Kovacevic Pittsburgh Tribune Review PIT Dickey Cueto Kershaw Kimbrel Gonzalez Tim Kurkjian ESPN.com WAS Kimbrel Dickey Kershaw Cueto Gonzalez Jack Magruder Fox Sports Arizona.com AZ Dickey Kershaw Cueto Gonzalez Kimbrel Bernie Miklasz St. Louis Post Dispatch STL Dickey Kershaw Cueto Gonzalez Lohse Bruce Miles Arlington Heights (IL) Daily Herald CHI Dickey Cueto Kershaw Gonzalez Cain Manny Navarro Miami Herald MIA Dickey Gonzalez Cueto Cain Kershaw Drew Olson ESPN Milwaukee.com MIL Dickey Cueto Kershaw Gonzalez Kimbrel Alexander Pavlovic San Jose Mercury News SF Dickey Kershaw Cueto Gonzalez Cain Mike Puma New York Post NY Dickey Kershaw Gonzalez Cueto Kimbrel Dennis Punzel Wisconsin State Journal MIL Dickey Kershaw Kimbrel Cueto Gonzalez Jim Salibury ComCastSportsNet.com PHI Dickey Gonzalez Kershaw Cueto Cain Patrick Saunders Denver Post COL Gonzalez Dickey Kershaw Cain Kimbrel Mark Schmetzer Reds Report CIN Dickey Gonzalez Cueto Kershaw Hamels John Shea San Francisco Chronicle SF Dickey Gonzalez Kershaw Kimbrel Cain Paul Sullivan Chicago Tribune CHI Dickey Gonzalez Cain Cueto Kershaw Alvin Valdez Hoy MIA Dickey Gonzalez Cueto Cain Lohse Mark Zuckerman CSNWashington.com WAS Dickey Gonzalez Kershaw Kimbrel Cueto