Minnesota Poll: Nearly half favor PolyMet copper mine

hide

An old taconite mine in Hoyt Lake will be brought back to life when PolyMet gets a permit to drill for copper and nickel in the surrounding area.

Photo: Renee Jones Schneider, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Among Minnesotans who have an opinion on the issue, the largest group supports approval for a controversial copper mine proposed for the northeast corner of the state, according to a new Star Tribune Minnesota Poll.

It found that 46 percent of Minnesotans who were polled want PolyMet Mining Corp.’s proposal to be approved; 21 percent say it should be rejected.

But a whopping one-third say they’re not sure — an indication that many Minnesotans are either uncertain about the trade-offs between economic development and environmental risks to one of the most beautiful parts of the state — or are simply not paying attention to the debate, said J. Brad Coker of Mason-Dixon Polling and Research, which conducted the poll.

“It’s a very high undecided,” Coker said.

PolyMet, a Canadian mining company, has proposed building the first of what could be many copper-nickel mines in the state, in an area just east of the Iron Range and stretching up toward the edge of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. The mining plan has raised hopes of an economic renaissance in northern Minnesota, but its predicted environmental impact, which is now open for public review, has been criticized by environmental watchdog groups and Minnesota Indian tribes, and drawn thousands of Minnesotans to recent public meetings.

PolyMet says it would create as many as 350 long-term mining jobs and hundreds of temporary construction jobs, drawing a groundswell of support among mining advocates. But copper mining also carries different and greater environmental risks to water than taconite mining. PolyMet’s $650 million open pit mine and processing plant would operate for 20 years but would require decades or even centuries of expensive water treatment to protect the lakes and rivers that ultimately drain into Lake Superior.

Some against the risk

Some of the people polled said the risk is not worthwhile.

“In the future, our biggest asset is going to be water,” said John Bode, 71, of Minneapolis. “I don’t think it’s worth taking the chance.”

But 33 percent of people polled were not as certain as Bode, a far higher share compared with the less than 10 percent who described themselves as undecided about such issues as raising the minimum wage and legalizing medical marijuana.

Coker said the difference is that both of those issues are drawing attention across the country — and that many Minnesotans are less likely to care about a mining controversy in a distant part of the state.

Regional differences clear

Regional differences in opinion on copper mining were clearly defined in the results. In northern Minnesota, 69 percent said they thought the state should approve PolyMet’s application.

John Cim, 72, of Cook, is one. He said he worked in the taconite industry for many years, retiring from a management job in 1999. He now lives near Lake Vermilion, which he loves for its clean, clear water, he said.

“I had no qualms about working for a taconite plant, taking resources out of the ground and using them,” he said. Te mining companies and the regulators were careful about protecting the environment, and, he said, PolyMet would be no different.

“This is part of our resources, part of Minnesota,” he said. “We should utilize what we have.”

Even in northern Minnesota, however, one-fifth of respondents said they were not sure about the mine, more than twice the number who said it should be rejected.

In the Twin Cities, a split

In the Twin Cities area as a whole, opinions were equally divided among the three possible answers, while in the suburbs, 45 percent said the mine should be approved. Again, there were significantly more in the suburbs who were not sure, 36 percent, compared with the number who thought the plan should be rejected.

There were few differences among age and income groups, but there was a clear split along gender lines. Men were more likely to approve than women, and more women than men said they were not sure.

“I’m all for bringing jobs to Minnesota,” said Jodi Denzer, 35, of St. Paul Park. “But I don’t think that we should do things that bring harm to our environment. I just don’t know enough about the situation.”

Partisan breakdowns

Republicans were evenly split between approval and “not sure,” with only 3 percent opposing the mine. Democrats said they support the plan, by a small plurality, but that reflects the weight of favorable opinions on the Iron Range, long a DFL enclave, said Coker.

The split among Democratic voters is forcing party leaders to walk a careful line in an election year between their traditional blue-collar base and environmentalists. Gov. Mark Dayton has said that he is keeping an open mind on the issue and plans to wait until he has more information before making a decision, likely late this year at the earliest.

The results were similar to polling that PolyMet and environmental groups have conducted, officials said.

Bruce Richardson, a spokesman for PolyMet, said that the company’s research shows some people are not engaged and are willing to let state regulators manage the decision. Aaron Klemz, communications director for Friends of the BWCA, an advocacy group, said that over time the public’s awareness of the mine and its environmental risks has increased substantially.

 

Josephine Marcotty • 612-673-7394

  • related content

  • Minnesota Poll results: PolyMet mine

    Friday February 21, 2014

    The Star Tribune Minnesota Poll surveyed 800 Minnesota adults Feb. 10-12, 2014. Respondents were reached on both landlines and cell...

  • PolyMet: Debate over copper mining in Minnesota

    Monday June 2, 2014

    PolyMet Mining Corp., which promises a $650 million investment and 300 to 360 jobs over 20 years, is only the first of many companies lining up to tap one of...

  • Minnesota Poll results

    Tuesday October 28, 2014

    Findings from the latest Star Tribune Minnesota Polls.

  • How the poll was conducted

    Today’s Star Tribune Minnesota Poll findings are based on interviews conducted Feb. 10-12 with 800 Minnesota adults via land line (75 percent) and cellphone (25 percent). The poll was conducted by Mason-Dixon Polling and Research Inc.

    Results of a poll based on 800 interviews will vary by no more than 3.5 percentage points, plus or minus, from the overall population 95 times out of 100. Margins are larger for groups within the sample, such as Democrats and Republicans.

    The self-identified party affiliation of the random sample is: 39 percent Democrat, 30 percent Republican, 26 percent independent or other party and 5 percent who said “none” or declined to cite a party affiliation.

    Sampling error does not take into account other sources of variation inherent in public opinion surveys, such as nonresponse, question wording or context effects. In addition, news events may have affected opinions during the period the poll was taken.

    Readers can e-mail questions to djmcgrath@startribune.com.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Will the Gophers bring home The Axe?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close