Review: "Color Blind,’ by Tom Dunkel

  • Article by: CHUCK HAGA , Special to the Star Tribune
  • Updated: April 13, 2013 - 4:05 PM

NONFICTION: With an unprecedented blend of black and white players, a town ball team in Depression-era North Dakota gained national prominence.

Tom Dunkel, author of "Color Blind."

 

A dozen years before Jackie Robinson pulled on a Brooklyn Dodgers jersey for the first time, black men and white men played baseball together — good baseball — in North Dakota.

In his new book, “Color Blind,” Tom Dunkel tells the largely unknown story of how a Bismarck car dealer turned a “town ball” team into a semi-pro powerhouse in the midst of the Depression. “Their team photo could have been taken yesterday … ambassadors from the multiracial future.”

Individual black players had made their way to North Dakota before, Dunkel notes, and in 1932, the team in Jamestown “quietly tapped into the Negro Leagues for several players,” including pitcher Wilber “Bullet” Rogan of the Kansas City Monarchs, who won 22 games in 25 starts.

Bismarck responded the following year. Neil Churchill, the car dealer, went through Abe Saperstein, founder of the Harlem Globetrotters basketball team, who said there was a lanky guy in Pittsburgh who might just be the best pitcher around, black or white. Bismarck didn’t lose a game the rest of that season after Satchel Paige signed on.

“Paige brought to the mound a jazz musician’s flair for improvisation and showmanship,” and Bismarck — pop. 11,000, including 46 black people — embraced him. Maybe mixed-race baseball was more acceptable on the northern plains, where immigrants and harsh weather had fostered a tradition of tolerance, Dunkel writes. “On the other hand, racial comity can be a product of indifference rather than open-mindedness. Blacks were in short supply … and not intruding on anybody’s comfort zone.”

This is a baseball story, a story of the importance people placed on having a winning team to cheer as farms, businesses and towns failed.

It’s also a history and sociology primer, telling of prairie populism and race and “dust flowing like snow,” and Sitting Bull riding in a parade before a Bismarck ballgame in 1889.

How good was the 1935 Bismarck team, half black and half white? Led by Paige, the team played in a national semi-pro tourney that year in Kansas. Among the 32 teams entered were an all-Japanese squad from California, an all-Indian team from Oklahoma and four all-black teams.

There was one integrated team, from Bismarck. Bismarck won.

Dunkel quotes a scout for the Cleveland Indians, who said in a radio interview during one of Bismarck’s games, “We wish we could find a chemical to bleach some of these colored boys. We could take some of those players up to the majors and win a pennant with ’em.”

He likely was thinking first of Paige, who would get his chance, but only well after his prime, after Robinson.

“It wasn’t until I signed up with Mr. Churchill that I found out I was going to be playing with white boys,” Paige said. “For the first time since I’d started throwing, I was going to have some of them on my side. It looked like they couldn’t hold out against me all the way after all.”

 

Chuck Haga, a longtime writer for the Star Tribune, now lives in North Dakota.

 

  • related content

  • "Color Blind," by Tom Dunkel.

  • Leroy “Satchel” Paige

  • COLOR BLIND: The forgotten team that broke baseball’s color line

    By: Tom Dunkel.

    Publisher: Atlantic Monthly Press, 345 pages, $25.

    Review: This remarkable story is about race relations, American history and the potential of the national pastime to affect the national conscience.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close