An influential man

Article by: CHUCK HAGA , Special to the Star Tribune
Updated: October 16, 2010 - 1:43 PM

Hole in the Day the Younger was a man pivotal in Ojibwe history as well as Minnesota history.

The Assassination of Hole in the Day by Anton Treuer

Photo: Feed Loader, Star Tribune

Camera Star Tribune photo galleries

Camera view larger

0
comments
resize text
print
buy reprints

Tweet
share

email
Email share

your name

your email

recipients email

+ add a comment add a comment

Anyone who has spent time wandering the lakes region of north central Minnesota has come upon the sign identifying Hole in the Day Lake north of Brainerd. Many probably think the poetic name was conjured by an ambitious land developer.

But Hole in the Day was a man -- two men, actually, father and son, remarkable leaders of the Ojibwe people at a time when Ojibwe life, customs and relations with others were undergoing profound change.

Hole in the Day the Younger especially deserves to be known, as much as Alexander Ramsey, his contemporary and first governor of Minnesota Territory, or any of the traders, missionaries and other white settlers who streamed into Minnesota in the mid-1800s. In his new book, "The Assassination of Hole in the Day," Anton Treuer makes a strong case for remembering Hole in the Day (Bagone-giizhig) as a pivotal figure in Minnesota as well as Ojibwe history.

Treuer, professor of Ojibwe at Bemidji State University, is the author of "Ojibwe in Minnesota" and several books on the language, whose preservation he champions. His grasp of its nuances and his extensive use of oral history provide new understanding of the personality, talents and achievements of this warrior/statesman.

Hole in the Day dressed sometimes in fine suits and made six trips to Washington, D.C., to meet with presidents. A gifted orator, he gave "some of the most stunning speeches that government officials had ever heard."

He was a paradoxical figure, denounced by enemies among his own people as arrogant and self-serving even as great numbers of Ojibwe (and U.S. agents) recognized him as "head man." Not a hereditary chief, he made himself into a traditional leader with "enormous, undeniable power," which he used both on behalf of his people and for personal gain.

"For decades he successfully led the Ojibwe toward peace with the Dakota, yet he killed and scalped many Dakota people with his own hands," Treuer writes. "He was incredibly bold -- in war, in council and in his personal life."

As testament to his stature, an account of his murder published in the St. Paul Pioneer was reprinted days later in the New York Times.

The title of Treuer's new book suggests a detailed re-examination of Hole in the Day's violent death, and it is that -- drawing in part on interviews with dozens of elders and the oral tradition that remains important in Ojibwe culture. Hole in the Day was killed by disaffected Ojibwe on June 27, 1868, as he began another trip to Washington.

But this is more than a Minnesota murder mystery. It provides insights into the evolution of clan structure, tribal governance and relations with the Dakota and other tribes since the time a century and a half ago when white pressure, the declining fur trade and other factors led to the cession of great tracts of land and the people's removal to reservations.

"He died young, but his people live on," Treuer writes. "Bagone-giizhig lives on with them -- not just among his numerous descendants at White Earth and Sandy Lake today, but among all Ojibwe people in spirit."

Chuck Haga, a former Star Tribune reporter, lives in Grand Forks, N.D.

read full article

THE ASSASSINATION OF HOLE IN THE DAY

By: Anton Treuer. Publisher: Borealis Books, 295 pages, $25.95.

Review: Treuer's portrait of the legendary Ojibwe leader finds him to be a complicated man who worked toward peace with other tribes while also engaging in bloody battles, a gifted orator and a man of great influence among both whites and tribes.

Events: 7 p.m. Oct. 26, Minnesota History Center, St. Paul; 7 p.m. Nov. 4, Grand Rapids Public Library; 7:30 p.m. Dec. 13, Magers & Quinn, 3038 Hennepin Av. S., Mpls.