Truckin' in Minnesota: Traditional distribution system is out of whack, ditto license fees

A weight-times-miles approach to vehicle license charges would make more sense, but big rigs on two-lane urban roads doesn't.

April 7, 2017 at 11:38PM
FILE - In this Wednesday, Aug. 24, 2016, file photo, truck and automobile traffic mix on Interstate 5, headed north through Fife, Wash., near the Port of Tacoma. Truckers are warning that a government plan to electronically limit the speed of tractor-trailer rigs will lead to highway traffic jams and even an increase in deadly run-ins with cars allowed to travel at faster speeds. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File) ORG XMIT: MIN2017040512321517
Semi-tractor trailer rigs are being used increasingly to make deliveries in urban neighborhoods on roads that were not designed for their weight. You don’t have to realize this is a problem until you get stuck behind one of these behemoths. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Our systems are out of whack. The editorial "Heavier trucks vs. the rest of us" (March 30) touched on one of the ways the use of and payment for roads have been skewed in recent years.

The traditional distribution system — products being carried on long haul semi-tractor trailers and then distributed to smaller trucks for delivery to the customer — has been dropped in favor of using the semi-tractor trailers to make the customer delivery.

This puts the big trucks on city streets that were never designed for their size and weight. I often see semi-tractor trailers on streets where they cannot make a turn without driving up onto a curb or median. Their additional size damages roads that were never built to carry that amount of weight in one vehicle, leading to faster deterioration of the streets, that we, the taxpayers, have to then pay to have rebuilt.

You don't really realize that the system is out of whack until you are stuck, waiting for a semi-tractor trailer painfully trying to turn around on a two-lane road because the driver is lost.

We need to enforce road weight and size limits. I do not care to subsidize a trucking company trying to save money.

Another system that is out of whack is the way the state charges for motor vehicle licenses. The age or value of a vehicle has nothing to do with its effect on the roads. The wear and tear on the roads is caused by weight and miles driven. Let's realign the system to price a vehicle license based on those factors.

Let's get rid of the attempts to promote social and economic agendas through licensing fees. Almost every motor vehicle licensed in this state is used for commerce at some point. Almost as many are used for pleasure. Let's get rid of the special price breaks afforded to some vehicles because of the occupation of the owner.

By going to a weight times miles approach for vehicle license fees, we won't have to worry about the type of fuel used to power a vehicle. Let's get the system back in shape by making it fair and simple.

Craig Wilson lives in Arden Hills.

about the writer

about the writer

Craig Wilson

More from Commentaries

See More
card image
Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune

When I was sheriff of Hennepin County, we worked with ICE.

card image
card image