Review: 'The Dust That Falls From Dreams,' by Louis de Bernières

FICTION: The dramatic life of an English family unfolds during World War I.

September 5, 2015 at 7:00PM
Louis De Bernieres Photo by Ivon Bartholomew
Louis de Bernières (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Although he's written 10 books, Louis de Bernières is best-known for his fourth, the endearing 1994 novel "Corelli's Mandolin."

Of course, it's not entirely fair to compare his new book, "The Dust That Falls From Dreams," to his old one. But when the old one is a revered novel that I've read, reread and watched (I wouldn't recommend the movie), it's hard not to make a few comparisons. Especially when there are striking similarities between the two.

Like "Mandolin," "The Dust That Falls from Dreams" is set in wartime — not the Greek islands during World War II, but in England before, during and after World War I.

And, like "Mandolin," "Dust" opens with a quick, quirky and brilliant history lesson — this time from Queen Victoria's last gasps (literally), through the brief, refreshing reign of King Edward and into the feverishly patriotic lead-up to the war.

We view that history largely through the lens of the McCosh family: the kooky "master" of which is a by-your-bootstraps Scottish success story, who's also a soft touch and afraid of his royalty-obsessed wife. And then there are the daughters, four who couldn't be more unalike.

One daughter is the perfect "blue-eyed Rosie," who, by age 12, is deeply in love with (and secretly engaged to) the equally perfect next-door neighbor boy, Ashbridge.

It's not a spoiler to tell you that these star-crossed lovers never wed, that Ash dies, that Rosie is bereft. The book — told alternately through an omniscient narrator, a series of first-person accounts, letters and diary excerpts — is full of foreshadowing, none of which, surprisingly, reduces its impact. (I still cried when Ash died.)

The story pivots from the battlefield to the McCosh mansion, pitting the graphic brutality of war against the everyday life of the family, which suddenly seems petty. Eventually, however, Mr. McCosh, his daughters and even his oblivious wife are dragged into the maw of the war, experiencing their own horrors.

Along the way, De Bernières introduces several complicated topics (chiefly love, but also class, the role of religion, sexual expression) and introduces us to a large cast of mostly colorful characters.

That may be the novel's weakness: It sacrifices intimacy for scope. We meet the sisters, but we don't come to know them deeply. I couldn't picture Sophie or know if it were Christabel or Ottilie speaking. And, at times, the story seems to lose its focus.

But these are minor complaints about a book that had me laughing, cringing and ultimately feeling a little spark of hope.

In that, "The Dust That Falls From Dreams" is very much like my old favorite, "Corelli's Mandolin."

Connie Nelson is the Star Tribune's senior editor for lifestyles.

"The Dust That Falls From Dreams," by Louis de Bernieres
“The Dust That Falls From Dreams,” by Louis de Bernieres (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Connie Nelson

Senior editor

Connie Nelson is the senior editor for lifestyles for the Star Tribune. 

See Moreicon

More from No Section

See More
FILE -- A rent deposit slot at an apartment complex in Tucker, Ga., on July 21, 2020. As an eviction crisis has seemed increasingly likely this summer, everyone in the housing market has made the same plea to Washington: Send money — lots of it — that would keep renters in their homes and landlords afloat. (Melissa Golden/The New York Times) ORG XMIT: XNYT58
Melissa Golden/The New York Times

It’s too soon to tell how much the immigration crackdown is to blame.