The writer of the Feb. 1 article "Let's not mince words: Banning books like 'Maus' is the work of bigots" rightly excoriates censorious parents and school boards that are behind a recent spate of book bans. There is simply no place for this sort of censorship in a country founded on enlightenment liberal values of freedom of thought and discourse.
I do, however, think the writer engages in rhetorical sleight of hand by omission when she highlights some of the books that populate the American Library Association's annual list of the most frequently banned books. Near the top of this list, as she explains, are books that address the experiences of historically marginalized groups. The implication is that this is the work of reactionary — possibly racist or transphobic — parents and school boards standing in the way of a progressive conception of social progress. This very likely is the case.
But left out of the article are books Nos. 7 and 8 on the ALA list: Harper Lee's "To Kill a Mockingbird" and John Steinbeck's "Of Mice and Men." Inconveniently for the book-banners-are-reactionary narrative, the impetus to ban these two titles most commonly comes from the political left. Just last week a Seattle-area school board voted to remove Lee's work from student required reading lists. This occurred in a county that voted 58% Democratic in the last presidential election.
Traditionally liberal values such as freedom of inquiry are not only instrumental to the search for truth, they are also social technologies that facilitate cohesion across a vast and increasingly diverse country. A collective commitment to refrain from book bans eliminates hyperpartisan debates about what is banned and who has standing to decide. In our tumultuous political environment, it's easy to forget that at the end of the day we need to find a way to live together and peacefully contribute to common civic projects. Fortunately, a transideological avoidance of censorship politics would make this a little easier.
Brian J. Krause, Minneapolis
•••
Regarding the article on the campaign across the country by citizens to ban books: Are these the same citizens who object to government programs and vaccinations because it will lead to communism? Well, guess what: Look no further, book banning will do it.
Linda Hove, Isanti, Minn.