If you want proof that football recruiting websites often miss on identifying the best players in the nation and that star-rating services often neglect great players, look no further than Denver Broncos star and former Gophers wide receiver Eric Decker, who will play a big role in this Sunday's Super Bowl against the Seattle Seahawks.
Decker was rated a two-star athlete coming out of Rocori High School in Cold Spring, despite having 2,156 receiving yards and 28 touchdowns in his high school career, and then-Gophers coach Glen Mason gave Decker his only Division I scholarship offer.
The first college coach to recognize Decker's talent was John Gagliardi at St. John's, who retired in 2012 with the most victories (489) of any coach in college football history. He said Decker would have played at his Division III school if the Gophers hadn't found him.
"I don't think very many people knew about how good he was here in our back yard at Cold Spring," Gagliardi said. "His high school quarterback [in Decker's sophomore year in high school, Alex Kofoed] was at St. John's, everything was here. He was pretty well set to go here, I think. He didn't register or anything because in the meantime, Glen Mason got a hold of the fact that he was a real good ballplayer and recruited him. That was the end of it for us."
Gagliardi was asked if any other major programs recruited Decker.
"I don't know that for a fact, but I don't think so," he said. "We looked like, he had attended all of our football camps and had his sister at [St. Benedict in St. Joseph, Minn.], they're only 10 miles away from us. It's like I say — his quarterback at high school, Kofoed, was over at St. John's playing for us and it looked like he might join him."
While Gagliardi was surprised no other colleges discovered Decker in high school, he also knows there are a lot of kids that go unnoticed despite their talent.
"We could see that he was pretty darn good, we were just surprised that nobody else [did]," he said. "There's a lot of good ballplayers out there, and they don't all get [noticed], there's just too many for everybody to see."