To love or die in Germany

REVIEW: James Valenti owns the show as a tragic poet in Minnesota Opera's staging of Massenet's "Werther."

For the Minnesota Star Tribune
January 30, 2012 at 6:45PM
James Valenti is the obsessive poet Werther in Minnesota Opera's production of the Jules Massenet work.
James Valenti is the obsessive poet Werther in Minnesota Opera's production of the Jules Massenet work. (Tim Campbell/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

If sentimentality is your thing, Jules Massenet's 1892 "Werther," which opened Saturday at Ordway Center in a new Minnesota Opera production marking the centenary of the composer's death, is an essential evening in the theater -- an unabashed, world-class, multi-hanky tear-jerker, engineered by a meticulous master.

But even if your musical diet is rigorously schmaltz-free, there are other pleasures to be savored in this, the first of Massenet's 30 operas to be mounted by the 49-year-old company, notably the singing of tenor James Valenti and mezzo-soprano Roxana Constantinescu.

The action, loosely based on a 1774 novel-in-letters by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe that triggered a wave of suicides across Europe, is uncomplicated. The title character, an obsessional poet -- described by a less-than-admiring critic of the opera as "a fiery-tempered young man who enjoys getting drunk on his own words" -- falls in love with Charlotte, a dutiful small-town girl who'd promised her dying mother that she'd marry the conventional Albert. Unable to dent her bourgeois propriety, Werther shoots himself -- in a barren room with "Liebe oder Tod" (Love or Death) scrawled defiantly across the wall -- and, after a prolonged love-death (not found in Goethe), expires in Charlotte's arms.

Director Kevin Newbury and his design team -- Allen Moyer (sets), Jessica Jahn (costumes), D.M. Wood (lighting) -- have shifted these doings forward a century or so, from Goethe's time to the smokestack Germany of Kaiser Wilhelm II. Almost the entire opera is played against a deliberately unbeautiful industrial landscape. This makes nonsense of Werther's ardent paeans to Nature (here represented by a single stunted tree) and of Massenet's often pastoral-sounding music. But the production's jarring visuals, light-years removed from the painterly stage pictures of yore, help inoculate the spectator against the opera's occasional mawkishness.

As Werther, Valenti owns the evening, a few opening-night wobbles notwithstanding. An alumnus of the company's Resident Artist program whose credits include La Scala and the Met, he now boasts a low register to rival his heroic top, and his French sounds better than it did in 2008. His singing is deeply musical; his professions of ecstasy in the famous "moonlight" scene of Act 1 -- an epitome of the composer's craft -- are wholly believable. He paces himself sagely.

Constantinescu is a warm Charlotte; her velvety mezzo manages to seem both alluring and maternal. She's particularly affecting in the company of soprano Angela Mortellaro, a vivacious scene-stealer as Charlotte's sister Sophie. Gabriel Preisser is an earnest Albert; Joseph Beutel cuts a sympathetic figure as Charlotte's father.

Conductor Christoph Campestrini draws playing of remarkable transparency and refinement from the orchestra, which could at times have been louder.

Roxana Constantinescu as Charlotte in the Minnesota Opera production of Werther
Music by Jules Massenet
Libretto by �douard Blau, Paul Milliet and Georges Hartmann
Based on Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's Die Leiden des jungen Werthers (1774)
Creative Team:
Conductor - Christoph Campestrini
Stage Director - Kevin Newbury
Set Designer - Allen Moyer
Costume Designer - Jessica Jahn
Lighting Designer - D. M. Wood
The Cast:
Werther, a poet - James Valenti
Charlotte - Roxana Constantinescu
Albert, her be
Roxana Constantinescu as Charlotte. (Photo By Michal Daniel/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Joseph Beutel as Le Bailli, Charlotte's father and Angela Mortellaro as Sophie, Charlotte's sister in the Minnesota Opera production of Werther
Music by Jules Massenet
Libretto by �douard Blau, Paul Milliet and Georges Hartmann
Based on Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's Die Leiden des jungen Werthers (1774)
Creative Team:
Conductor - Christoph Campestrini
Stage Director - Kevin Newbury
Set Designer - Allen Moyer
Costume Designer - Jessica Jahn
Lighting Designer - D. M. Wood
The Cast:
Werther, a poet
Joseph Beutel as Charlotte's father and Angela Mortellaro as Sophie, Charlotte's sister. (Photo By Michal Daniel/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writers

about the writers

Larry Fuchsberg

LARRY FUCHSBERG

More from Minnesota Star Tribune

See More
card image
Provided/Sahan Journal

Family members and a lawyer say they have been blocked from access to the bedside of Bonfilia Sanchez Dominguez, while her husband was detained and shipped to Texas within 24 hours.

card image