Rand: Getting the right QB is tough, as the Dalton example proves

  • Updated: January 6, 2014 - 10:37 PM

Would Vikings fans settle for a quarterback like Andy Dalton, who plays well — until the playoffs.

hide

Bengals quarterback Andy Dalton has excelled in the regular season but struggled in the playoffs the past three years.

Photo: Al Behrman, Associated Press

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

In Minnesota, we pine — or at least we think we do — for a young quarterback like Andy Dalton (who could have been drafted in 2011 instead of Christian Ponder).

Dalton started all 48 games in his first three seasons with the Bengals, leading them to the playoffs all three times. His yardage and TD totals have increased every year as he gets more comfortable. He is a player around which a team can build … Or is he?

The narrative on Dalton and others like him appears to be changing in the pass-happy NFL. The term “game-manager,” once used at least with acceptance to describe a quarterback who was steady and didn’t make a lot of mistakes, is now used with derision.

And we’re left to wonder: Is it good enough to have a solid-but-not-spectacular quarterback like Dalton?

That’s a big question in Cincinnati, where Dalton has one year left on his rookie contract and a pretty good résumé (yearly averages of nearly 3,800 yards and 27 TD passes) … but three consecutive one-and-done playoff appearances in which he has thrown one TD pass to go with six interceptions and a 56.2 passer rating.

Is it better to have a quarterback who can get you to the playoffs but might not have a higher ceiling than that … or to constantly have to keep starting over in the search for stability, as has been the case with the Vikings for much of their post-Fran Tarkenton history?

Is Dalton akin to the Falcons’ Matt Ryan — steady in the regular season, but questionable when the level of competition is turned up? Does he have a dash of early Peyton Manning — a quarterback who will continue to get better and shake off playoff butterflies on the way to becoming an elite Super Bowl champion? Or is he just an OK quarterback on a talented roster?

Three years should tell us that he’s not Manning and he never will be. But Dalton also seems to be better than average. Perhaps Ryan — who also lost his first three playoff starts and has overseen notable postseason flops — is the best comparison.

So is it good enough to have a quarterback like that?

Someday — maybe soon — that could be a big question in Minnesota. It makes the NFL draft even more of a crap shoot than ever. These days, it might not even be good enough to draft a perfectly good quarterback.

MICHAEL RAND

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Toronto - LP: A. Loup 4 FINAL
Cleveland - WP: J. Outman 6
LA Angels - LP: H. Santiago 1 FINAL
Detroit - WP: R. Porcello 2
Atlanta - LP: G. Schlosser 3 FINAL
NY Mets - WP: J. Valverde 4
Seattle - LP: T. Wilhelmsen 2 FINAL
Miami - WP: M. Dunn 3
St. Louis - LP: S. Maness 2 FINAL
Washington - WP: R. Soriano 3
Milwaukee - WP: Z. Duke 3 FINAL
Pittsburgh - LP: J. Gomez 2
NY Yankees - WP: P. Claiborne 5 FINAL
Tampa Bay - LP: H. Bell 1
Minnesota - WP: P. Hughes 8 FINAL
Kansas City - LP: Y. Ventura 3
Cincinnati - WP: H. Bailey 8 FINAL
Chicago Cubs - LP: C. Villanueva 2
Chicago WSox - WP: E. Johnson 16 FINAL
Texas - LP: R. Ross Jr. 2
Houston - LP: B. Peacock 1 FINAL
Oakland - WP: J. Chavez 4
Philadelphia 10 Bottom 9th Inning
Colorado 9
San Francisco - WP: T. Lincecum 4 FINAL
San Diego - LP: R. Erlin 3
Arizona - LP: J. Collmenter 1 FINAL
Los Angeles - WP: J. Wright 4
Baltimore 3 Top 4th Inning
Boston 0
Dallas 85 FINAL
San Antonio 90
Charlotte 88 FINAL
Miami 99
Washington 48 2nd Qtr 0:34
Chicago 54
Portland 8:30 PM
Houston
Philadelphia 4 FINAL
NY Rangers 2
Detroit 1 FINAL
Boston 4
Tampa Bay 0 2nd Prd 19:50
Montreal 1
Los Angeles 9:00 PM
San Jose
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Date/Opponent Time W L Score
2013 preseason     
Aug 9 - vs. Houston 7 pmX27-13
Aug 16 - at Buffalo 6 pmX20-16
Aug 25 - at San Francisco 7 pmX34-14
Aug 29 - vs. Tennessee 7 pmX24-23
2013 regular season     
Sep 8 - at Detroit NoonX34-24
Sep 15 - at Chicago NoonX31-30
Sep 22 - vs. Cleveland NoonX31-27
Sep 29 - vs. Pittsburgh (in London) NoonX34-27
Oct 6 - Bye
Oct 13 - vs. Carolina NoonX35-10
Oct 21 - at. NY Giants 7:40 pmX23-7
Oct 27 - vs. Green Bay 7:30 pmX44-31
Nov 3 - at Dallas NoonX27-23
Nov 7 - vs. Washington 7:25 pmX34-27
Nov 17 - at Seattle 3:25 pmX41-20
Nov. 24 - at Green Bay Noon26-26
Dec 1 - vs. Chicago NoonX23-20
Dec 8 - at Baltimore NoonX29-26
Dec 15 - vs. Philadelphia NoonX48-30
Dec 22 - at Cincinnati NoonX42-14
Dec 29 - vs. Detroit NoonX14-13

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Which quarterback is best in the NFL draft?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close