MLB Insider: Twins dominated by all AL Cy Young candidates

  • Article by: PHIL MILLER , Star Tribune
  • Updated: September 7, 2013 - 7:47 PM

Unsure. Leading Cy Young Award candidates all dominate against Twins.

The Tigers’ Max Scherzer has all the wins you expect in a Cy Young winner, but exceptional run support explains some of that.

The Twins have been no help at all.

I received my official BBWAA ballot for the American League Cy Young Award recently, a personal invitation to become a target for passionate fans in a race that may turn into one of the most difficult choices I’ve ever faced. There are still three weeks to go, and perhaps someone will separate himself in that time the way Clayton Kershaw seems to have managed to do already in the National League.

But in trying to choose among (in alphabetical order, so no e-mails about my bias yet, please) Yu Darvish, Felix Hernandez and Max Scherzer, with David Price, Chris Sale, Anibal Sanchez and James Shields a few steps behind, the Twins have remained remarkably unbiased. They have been dominated by each of them.

I understand the “eye test” shouldn’t count for much when considering a season’s worth of work, and I realize that one commanding performance, particularly against an offensively challenged team like these late-season Twins, doesn’t accurately reflect how that pitcher fared the other 30-plus times he pitched. Still, there’s no denying that it’s human nature to welcome confirmation of your opinions by evidence in front of you. And I watch the Twins for a living.

So when Hernandez allowed only three measly singles in eight innings against the Twins on July 26, I remember thinking “That was a Cy Young performance,” even after he gave up a ninth-inning run to send the game to extra innings.

It happened again last week. Darvish took a no-hitter into the seventh inning, and looked simply unhittable. Well, until Chris Herrmann and Justin Morneau spoiled his perfection with back-to-back homers. Strangely, the Twins have been shut down by both Hernandez and Darvish, and won both games.

Scherzer hasn’t faced the Twins since May, odd given how frequently they meet, but he may well get one more shot when the Tigers visit Target Field in the season’s final week. But two of his 19 wins have come at the Twins’ expense, and he has posted a 2.70 ERA in those games.

Yeah, the Twins seem to be neutral in this race. So who deserves to win it?

Scherzer, of course, is a runaway leader in victories, but that statistic has little meaning, particularly considering Scherzer has received the most offensive support, nearly six runs per game, of anyone in the game. But his case is strong regardless — his ERA of 2.88 is second in the league behind Sanchez, and his Wins Above Replacement (WAR), which measures overall value toward winning, ranks behind only Sale (as calculated by baseball-reference.com) or Hernandez (as calculated by FanGraphs). He also leads the league in fewest baserunners (walks and hits per inning) and is second in strikeouts and strikeout rate.

Darvish, however, is the runaway leader in those strikeout categories. With an ERA of 2.91 and an average of 12 strikeouts per nine innings, he’s turning into a latter-day Nolan Ryan in Texas. He appeared primed to move into the favorite’s role in the race, but suddenly, Texas has lost his past four starts.

Hernandez is better than he was when he won the award in 2010, striking out more hitters per inning and walking fewer. He leads FanGraphs’ WAR calculation, though he may be hurt by being out of the pennant race.

With three weeks left, this ballot remains a mystery. But September makes a wonderful tiebreaker.

Strong in September

Josmil Pinto is off to a great start in his first September in the major leagues. But he’s not the first Twin to do so. Here are the best Septembers by Twins rookies, as measured by OPS (on-base percentage plus slugging).

Player OPS Year

Chris Parmelee 1.035 2011

Steve Lombardozzi .958 1985

Willie Norwood .954 1977

  • related content

  • Sunday Insider: Central Intelligence

    Saturday September 7, 2013

    CENTRAL INTELLIGENCEIt’s been a frustrating season for Chicago. But several of the White Sox say their troubles were put in...

  • The Rangers’ Yu Darvish is a dominating pitcher, as seen in his strikeout numbers, but his team has lost his past four starts.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Seattle
Detroit 16 2nd Qtr
Philadelphia 28
Portland 21 1st Qtr 0:01
Cleveland 31
Sacramento 6:30 PM
Toronto
Boston 7:00 PM
Minnesota
Dallas 7:00 PM
Houston
Denver 7:00 PM
New Orleans
Brooklyn 7:00 PM
Atlanta
Oklahoma City 7:00 PM
New York
Charlotte 7:30 PM
San Antonio
LA Clippers 8:00 PM
Utah
Washington 9:30 PM
Phoenix
Toronto 6:30 PM
New Jersey
Pittsburgh 7:00 PM
Washington
Chicago 9:30 PM
Los Angeles
Temple 25 1st Half 5:38
UCF 14
Winthrop 23 1st Half 6:03
Coastal Carolina 24
Lafayette 16 1st Half 6:35
Colgate 21
Northeastern 12 1st Half 7:20
Drexel 11
Wake Forest 21 1st Half 7:48
Florida State 12
Rhode Island 19 1st Half 6:55
Fordham 24
Delaware 29 1st Half 6:27
James Madison 21
South Carolina 19 1st Half 7:21
LSU 20
New Hampshire 19 1st Half 6:59
Maine 6
Seton Hall 28 1st Half 3:07
Marquette 25
Binghamton 20 1st Half 8:27
UMBC 10
American Univ 24 1st Half 6:51
Navy 22
Elon 12 1st Half 7:00
UNC-Wilmington 27
Wright State 28 1st Half 5:57
Oakland 19
Minnesota 20 1st Half 5:04
Penn State 28
Duquesne 15 1st Half 6:40
Richmond 35
SMU 15 1st Half 6:36
South Florida 18
Hartford 18 1st Half 6:17
Stony Brook 14
Albany 15 1st Half 4:11
Vermont 11
Hofstra 15 1st Half 6:17
William & Mary 42
UNC-Asheville 22 1st Half 5:53
Longwood 17
Radford 6:30 PM
Char Southern
Holy Cross 0 Postponed
Loyola-Maryland 0
Duke 0 1st Half 20:00
Notre Dame 0
Texas Tech 2 1st Half 19:15
Oklahoma 0
Oregon State 7:00 PM
Arizona State
Morehead State 7:00 PM
Austin Peay
Drake 7:00 PM
Bradley
Lehigh 7:00 PM
Bucknell
Rice 7:00 PM
Houston
Missouri State 7:00 PM
Illinois State
Loyola-Chicago 7:00 PM
Wichita State
Nebraska Omaha 7:00 PM
South Dakota St
Northern Iowa 7:05 PM
Southern Ill
Louisville 8:00 PM
Boston College
St Johns 8:00 PM
Creighton
East Carolina 8:00 PM
Memphis
Georgia Tech 8:00 PM
Miami-Florida
Miss State 8:00 PM
Ole Miss
Clemson 8:00 PM
NC State
Indiana 8:00 PM
Purdue
Kansas 8:00 PM
TCU
Oregon 9:00 PM
Arizona
Air Force 9:00 PM
San Jose St
Stanford 10:00 PM
Washington
Rider 56 FINAL
Siena 49
Dayton 76 FINAL
Richmond 62
Eastern Kentucky 53 FINAL
Jacksonville St 73
Saint Josephs 0 Postponed
Saint Louis 0
UMBC 26 1st Half 7:39
Binghamton 15
Akron 17 1st Half 5:26
Ohio U 32
Ball State 26 1st Half 6:14
Miami-Ohio 13
Memphis 16 1st Half 6:06
Cincinnati 14
East Carolina 8 1st Half 10:55
(2) Connecticut 29
Murray State 21 1st Half 3:40
Eastern Illinois 28
Kent State 24 1st Half 6:33
Central Michigan 24
UT Martin 34 1st Half 3:49
Tennessee St 24
Eastern Michigan 18 1st Half 9:58
Western Mich 23
Bucknell 18 1st Half 7:21
Lehigh 20
Indiana 12 1st Half 7:39
Michigan State 21
Colgate 29 1st Half 6:29
Lafayette 15
Fordham 21 1st Half 5:53
Davidson 17
Duquesne 19 1st Half 6:39
St Bonaventure 15
George Mason 22 1st Half 5:18
VA Commonwealth 27
Detroit 14 1st Half 4:51
Youngstown St 25
Army 0 Postponed
Boston U 0
Loyola-Maryland 0 Postponed
Holy Cross 0
SMU 7:00 PM
Tulsa
Oklahoma St 7:00 PM
Kansas State
West Virginia 7:00 PM
Texas Tech
Denver 7:00 PM
South Dakota
Northwestern St 7:00 PM
Central Arkansas
Austin Peay 7:00 PM
SIU-Edwardsville
Kansas 7:00 PM
Iowa State
Bowling Green 7:00 PM
Northern Ill
Penn State 7:00 PM
Minnesota
San Jose St 8:00 PM
Air Force
Boise State 8:00 PM
Colorado State
Utah State 8:00 PM
Wyoming
San Diego State 9:00 PM
Fresno State
Nevada 9:00 PM
UNLV
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: How optimistic are you about the 2015 Twins?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close