Change is pondered in southeast, where goal is bigger bucks

  • Article by: DOUG SMITH , Star Tribune
  • Updated: March 29, 2009 - 10:19 AM
hide

Whitetail buck

Photo: Bill Marchel, Special to the Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

ROCHESTER - The deer season in southeastern Minnesota would be shifted a week later and cross-tagging of bucks there would be illegal if Jim Vagts had his way.

And there appears to be at least a chance he will.

The goal would be to increase the number of bigger bucks by reducing the number of yearling bucks harvested each fall.

"Some deer hunters want more from their hunting experience than just harvesting a deer,'' said Vagts, of the Bluffland Whitetails Association, a southeast Minnesota group that has pushed for significant deer management changes in the region.

Vagts, of Harmony, Minn., was among about 75 hunters and wildlife officials from Minnesota and other states who gathered here Friday at a deer management roundtable to discuss possible changes to management of the southeast herd, whether regulations could be adopted to help create bigger bucks, what ramifications the changes would have on the deer herd and hunters -- and whether hunters would accept them.

The issue has been controversial. Some hunters are less interested in shooting a big buck than in just bagging a deer. Leaders of the Minnesota Deer Hunters Association (MDHA), who attended the session, said the group opposes mandatory regulations aimed at growing larger bucks or restricting party hunting. And a bill was introduced at the Legislature this session to prevent shifting the southeast deer hunting dates.

But the winds of change seem to be blowing.

"We're open to considering changes,'' said Dave Schad, Department of Natural Resources Fish and Wildlife director, who attended the session along with several other DNR leaders. Interest and support for such ideas has grown, especially in the southeast, Schad said.

"We can continue to debate it for years, but we'll never know until we try it,'' Schad said. "But we won't do anything to compromise our ability to manage the deer population.''

The strong DNR presence at the session, he said, "is an indication of how important an issue this is.'' He said the agency likely would offer a pilot proposal in a limited area. "We're committed to exploring this,'' he said.

The DNR intends to survey 3,000 southeast hunters this summer to ask their opinions on a variety of potential changes, including antler-point restrictions, moving the season later and eliminating cross-tagging of bucks, which allows a hunter to shoot a buck for another member of his party. Public input would be sought too, before any proposals are made, officials said.

No changes will be made this year. But changes could come in 2010. Talk is focusing only on southeast Minnesota, which has a higher deer density than northern Minnesota.

"I see no interest in the northeast for any of this,'' said Lou Cornicelli, DNR deer specialist. "There's some interest in the northwest.''

A 2005 DNR survey of southeastern Minnesota deer hunters showed 73 percent were satisfied with their hunt, but just 45 percent were satisfied with the quality of bucks. When given potential alternatives, 51 percent supported antler point restrictions, 48 percent supported no cross-tagging for bucks and 34 percent supported moving the deer season. Overall, 69 percent supported regulations to increase mature bucks.

But Cornicelli said wildlife managers and hunters have to be cautious about how to interpret such responses. Because surveys show that hunter satisfaction with some of these more restrictive regulations tends to become more popular with time as hunter adapt to them and see the results. For example, earn-a-buck restrictions were imposed at Itasca State Park several years ago as an experiment. Even though buck harvest in the park declined, the popularity of the earn-a-buck restriction increased significantly over three years. Hunters are seeing more bucks and bigger bucks there.

"We can't change regulations without public support, but we really have to assume there will be increased satisfaction and support over time,'' Cornicelli said. "You may have only 40 or 45 percent support the first year, but you may have 60 percent support after three years.''

Cornicelli said he often hears from hunters who say they will quit hunting if more restrictive regulations are imposed. He doesn't think that will happen with a restriction on cross-tagging bucks.

"I don't think they'd quit if you tell them they have to shoot their own bucks, and not their buddy's,'' Cornicelli said. "We're one of the few states that allows that.''

Requiring a lottery for buck licenses, on the other hand, could force some hunters to quit or go elsewhere, he said.

Antler-point restrictions is another option, though Vagt said his group doesn't want them. Only bucks with a certain number of points could be shot. The idea, again, is to spare young bucks so they will grow bigger. But there is a price to pay.

"Antler-point restrictions will restrict harvest,'' said Marrett Grund, DNR farmland deer biologist. "Hunters need to be aware that hunter success rates would significantly decline.''

In Minnesota, about 60 percent of bucks shot are yearlings, among the highest in the nation.

"But we have lots of hunters, a longer season and allow party hunting for bucks,'' Cornicelli said.

Friday's session was sponsored by the Bluffland Whitetails Association.

"We don't want people to think we're elitist or a trophy group,'' said Tom McConnell, a Bluffland Whitetails board member from Eyota.

He said the group simply wants to increase the opportunity for hunters to shoot a quality deer. The group is concerned that the hunting season comes at the peak of the rut, when bucks are especially vulnerable.

There's also concern that removing bucks from the population before they have bred could hurt the gene pool.

Also attending were representatives from the Quality Deer Management Association, the MDHA and the Minnesota Bow Hunters Association. A recent Bow Hunters Association survey showed 56 percent supported some type of quality deer management. Deer biologists from Missouri and Iowa also attended and described deer management in their states.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

Toronto - LP: D. Hutchison 2 FINAL
NY Yankees - WP: M. Tanaka 5
Washington - WP: S. Strasburg 2 FINAL
Miami - LP: N. Eovaldi 1
NY Mets - WP: J. deGrom 10 FINAL
Atlanta - LP: E. Santana 2
Boston - WP: J. Kelly 3 FINAL
Baltimore - LP: M. Gonzalez 2
Milwaukee - LP: W. Peralta 0 FINAL
Pittsburgh - WP: V. Worley 1
Chicago WSox - WP: J. Danks 10 FINAL
Tampa Bay - LP: N. Karns 5
Cleveland - WP: C. Kluber 7 FINAL
Minnesota - LP: A. Swarzak 2
Detroit - LP: R. Porcello 2 FINAL
Kansas City - WP: J. Guthrie 5
Seattle 3 Top 9th Inning
Houston 8
Los Angeles 7 Bottom 8th Inning
Chicago Cubs 5
Texas 1 Bottom 6th Inning
LA Angels 1
Philadelphia 4 Top 5th Inning
Oakland 4
San Francisco 0 Bottom 5th Inning
San Diego 0
Arizona 0 Bottom 5th Inning
Colorado 4
Cincinnati - A. Simon 7:05 PM
St. Louis - L. Lynn
San Diego 22 FINAL
Buffalo 10
Dallas 34 FINAL
St. Louis 31
Washington 34 FINAL
Philadelphia 37
Houston 17 FINAL
NY Giants 30
Minnesota 9 FINAL
New Orleans 20
Tennessee 7 FINAL
Cincinnati 33
Baltimore 23 FINAL
Cleveland 21
Green Bay 7 FINAL
Detroit 19
Indianapolis 44 FINAL
Jacksonville 17
Oakland 9 FINAL
New England 16
San Francisco 14 3rd Qtr
Arizona 6
Denver 3 2nd Qtr 2:54
Seattle 10
Kansas City 7 2nd Qtr 1:42
Miami 0
Pittsburgh 7:30 PM
Carolina
Chicago 9/22/14 7:30 PM
NY Jets
NY Giants 9/25/14 7:25 PM
Washington
Columbus 4 FINAL
Carolina 3
Buffalo 0 1st Prd 2:21
Washington 1
St. Louis 5:30 PM
Columbus
Calgary 7:00 PM
Edmonton
Edmonton 7:00 PM
Calgary
Old Dominion 45 FINAL
Rice 42
Troy 0 FINAL
(12) Georgia 66
Georgia Tech 27 FINAL
Virginia Tech 24
Eastern Mich 14 FINAL
(9) Michigan State 73
Iowa 24 FINAL
Pittsburgh 20
Bowling Green 17 FINAL
(19) Wisconsin 68
Maryland 34 FINAL
Syracuse 20
Tulane 13 FINAL
Duke 47
Hawaii 12 FINAL
Colorado 21
Marshall 48 FINAL
Akron 17
North Carolina 41 FINAL
(23) East Carolina 70
Army 21 FINAL
Wake Forest 24
Virginia 33 FINAL
(20) BYU 41
(6) Texas A&M 58 FINAL
SMU 6
Rutgers 31 FINAL
Navy 24
Central Mich 10 FINAL
Kansas 24
Utah 26 FINAL
Michigan 10
Florida 21 FINAL
(3) Alabama 42
Louisville 34 FINAL
FIU 3
Fla Atlantic 19 FINAL
Wyoming 20
Indiana 31 FINAL
Missouri 27
San Jose St 7 FINAL
Minnesota 24
Texas State 35 FINAL
Illinois 42
Massachusetts 7 FINAL
Penn State 48
Georgia State 14 FINAL
Washington 45
Appalachian St 20 FINAL
Southern Miss 21
(14) Miss State 34 FINAL
(17) LSU 29
Northern Ill 14 FINAL
Arkansas 52
Middle Tennessee 17 FINAL
Memphis 36
Utah State 14 FINAL
Arkansas State 21
Miami-Ohio 24 FINAL
Cincinnati 31
Idaho 24 FINAL
Ohio U 36
Ball State 23 FINAL
Toledo 34
(13) So Carolina 48 FINAL
Vanderbilt 34
(4) Oklahoma 45 FINAL
West Virginia 33
Ga Southern 28 FINAL
South Alabama 6
UNLV 14 FINAL
Houston 47
Miami-Florida 31 FINAL
(21) Nebraska 41
New Mexico 38 FINAL
New Mexico St 35
Clemson 17 FINAL
(1) Florida State 23
California 45 FINAL
Arizona 49
San Diego St 7 FINAL
Oregon State 28
(2) Oregon 38 FINAL
Washington St 31
Louisiana 9 FINAL
Boise State 34
Texas Tech 9/25/14 6:30 PM
(24) Oklahoma State
Appalachian St 9/25/14 6:30 PM
Ga Southern
(11) UCLA 9/25/14 9:00 PM
(15) Arizona State
Middle Tennessee 9/26/14 7:00 PM
Old Dominion
Fresno State 9/26/14 7:00 PM
New Mexico
Texas-El Paso 9/27/14 11:00 AM
(25) Kansas State
Tennessee 9/27/14 11:00 AM
(12) Georgia
Vanderbilt 9/27/14 11:00 AM
Kentucky
Wyoming 9/27/14 11:00 AM
(9) Michigan State
Northwestern 9/27/14 11:00 AM
Penn State
TCU 9/27/14 11:00 AM
SMU
Iowa 9/27/14 11:00 AM
Purdue
Tulane 9/27/14 11:00 AM
Rutgers
So Florida 9/27/14 11:00 AM
(19) Wisconsin
Colorado State 9/27/14 11:30 AM
Boston College
Western Mich 9/27/14 11:30 AM
Virginia Tech
Maryland 9/27/14 12:30 PM
Indiana
Akron 9/27/14 12:30 PM
Pittsburgh
Bowling Green 9/27/14 2:00 PM
Massachusetts
Arkansas 9/27/14 2:30 PM
(6) Texas A&M
Kent State 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Virginia
Western Ky 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Navy
Minnesota 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Michigan
Wake Forest 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Louisville
FIU 9/27/14 2:30 PM
UAB
(1) Florida State 9/27/14 2:30 PM
NC State
Miami-Ohio 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Buffalo
Colorado 9/27/14 3:00 PM
California
Louisiana Tech 9/27/14 3:00 PM
(5) Auburn
Texas 9/27/14 3:00 PM
Kansas
Temple 9/27/14 3:00 PM
Connecticut
(16) Stanford 9/27/14 3:15 PM
Washington
TX-San Antonio 9/27/14 4:00 PM
Fla Atlantic
South Alabama 9/27/14 4:00 PM
Idaho
Cincinnati 9/27/14 5:00 PM
(22) Ohio State
Rice 9/27/14 6:00 PM
Southern Miss
Missouri 9/27/14 6:00 PM
(13) So Carolina
Boise State 9/27/14 6:00 PM
Air Force
North Carolina 9/27/14 6:00 PM
Clemson
Central Mich 9/27/14 6:00 PM
Toledo
Troy 9/27/14 6:00 PM
ULM
New Mexico St 9/27/14 6:30 PM
(17) LSU
Memphis 9/27/14 6:30 PM
(10) Ole Miss
Duke 9/27/14 6:30 PM
Miami-Florida
Texas State 9/27/14 7:00 PM
Tulsa
Washington St 9/27/14 7:00 PM
Utah
(8) Notre Dame 9/27/14 7:00 PM
Syracuse
(7) Baylor 9/27/14 7:00 PM
Iowa State
UNLV 9/27/14 7:00 PM
San Diego St
Illinois 9/27/14 8:00 PM
(21) Nebraska
Oregon State 9/27/14 9:30 PM
(18) USC
Nevada 9/27/14 9:30 PM
San Jose St
Chivas USA 0 FINAL
Toronto FC 3
Toronto 40 FINAL
Brt Columbia 23
Edmonton 23 FINAL
Hamilton 25
Calgary 15 FINAL
Montreal 31
Ottawa 22
Saskatchewan 10
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close