Page 2 of 2 Previous

Continued: 'Gentleman': A concept put asunder

  • Article by: D.J. TICE , Star Tribune
  • Last update: June 11, 2014 - 6:28 PM

The portrait of modern American manhood on #YesAllWomen suggests they may have been right.

Even as unconventional a Victorian as George Bernard Shaw shared his era’s understanding that nature does not endow men with spontaneous “good character where women are concerned” — that a well-mannered male is a social creation. And of course society today still takes the brute out of most men. That was the essence of the common rebuttal — on #NotAllMen and elsewhere — to the eruption of female discontent in recent weeks.

Another line of argument dismisses talk of an epidemic of rape, saying this ignores plain evidence that levels of violence have fallen in recent years and often involves stretching the definition of “rape” beyond recognition. Maybe so. But it is another sign of decay if even today’s “conservatives” believe that sexual recklessness has to be rape to be wrong.

In a memorable essay a decade ago, Moore, a scholar, educator and ex-Marine, conceded that not all modern men are barbarians.

The rest, he said, are wimps.

That’s one way to understand the need for “bystander intervention” counseling.

“Wimps make worthless watchdogs,” Moore wrote, which “has nothing to do with size or physique. … ‘It is not the size of the dog in the fight, but the size of the fight in the dog’ that matters. Many of today’s young men seem to have no fight in them at all. Not for them to rescue damsels in distress from the barbarians.”

Everywhere one looks today, there are signs that something is going wrong with men. Statistics tell us they are working less, marrying less, enrolling in college less, succeeding in school at all levels less. Today’s huge population of single-mother households — whatever its many causes and effects — is at bottom evidence of an alarming de-socialization of males.

Many inexorable forces are at work here — economic, social, technological. But cultural conservatives insist one factor is within our control. It is a fashionable contemporary ideology of disdain for “manliness” — for even constructive expressions of the innate male zest for competition and physicality and everything that might be expressed by “fight.”

This war on “traditional manhood,” Moore wrote, is finishing the job of turning men into either lonely “rogues” or lonely “namby-pambies.” Both lack any sense of having a unique, important role in society — something women (as real or potential bearers of new life) receive more fully as a biological birthright.

At the risk of hypocrisy (as a child of the Sixties) and of expressing what is today a wholly forbidden idea, one even has to wonder, along with Moore and others, how well the sexual revolution is actually working out.

Winning a woman’s acceptance, and favor, is, to say the least, a very big deal to men. Many have always misbehaved in its pursuit and no doubt always will.

But men may behave even worse in a social environment where shallow charm, deception and even whining can too easily secure this elemental goal, because then they lack the profound incentive males once had to be neither barbarian nor wimp — to strive instead to be seen as a provider, a protector, a gentleman.

Whatever the problem is, we modern males need to shape up, and to shape up one another.

But it’s a big job, and if it’s not too unmanly to say so, we may need some intervention.

 

D.J. Tice is at Doug.Tice@startribune.com.

  • related content

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

  • about opinion

  • The Opinion section is produced by the Editorial Department to foster discussion about key issues. The Editorial Board represents the institutional voice of the Star Tribune and operates independently of the newsroom.

  • Submit a letter or commentary
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close