A trove of early ceramics shows the mindset of ancient humans: More metaphor, less blood.
We know them best for their stone tools and intrepid mammoth hunting. But new discoveries in Croatia suggest that ice age humans made evocative ceramic art far more regularly than once believed.
Thirty-six fragments of fired clay, excavated in the Vela Spila cave on an island off the Adriatic coast, make up the second-largest collection found so far of the earliest human experiments with ceramic art. They are 15,000 to 17,500 years old -- the first European evidence of ceramic art after the ice sheets stopped spreading.
The oldest and largest collection, made about 30,000 years ago and found in the Czech Republic, includes a famously corpulent nude figurine known as the Venus of Dolni Vestonice. Apart from that, little fired ceramic art remains from the time before the explosion of ceramic pot-making 10,000 years ago, after the ice sheets retreated and early humans settled down to farm.
That led paleontologists to believe that ceramic art was uncommon among the highly mobile people of the ice age. But Rebecca Farbstein, the University of Cambridge archaeologist who described the Croatian collection in the journal PLoS One, said the work was not so unusual after all.
"The history of ceramic technology is longer and more diverse than we originally thought," she said.
The most lifelike piece found at Vela Spila (the term is Croatian for big cave) is the tiny dark brown torso and foreleg of an animal, possibly a horse or deer. But when the piece was uncovered in 2001, the team stuffed it into a bag without identification. "It was overlooked because no one expected to find ceramics in the Paleolithic," Farbstein said.
'Life was lived by more than stone spear point'
Five years later, someone looked in the bag and realized what the figure was. When scientists went back to the cave that year to excavate further, they found the other 35 ceramic art pieces.
Olga Soffer, an emerita professor of anthropology at the University of Illinois who has worked on the Czech ceramics, said the find reinforced the idea that ceramic work -- a major, complex technological breakthrough in human history -- was invented for art rather than utility. In turn, that helps flesh out the modern understanding of how early human minds worked: more metaphor, less blood. "Life was lived by more than stone spear point," Soffer said. "It gets us away from the Hemingway, mega-macho male stuff."
Farbstein said her analysis of the Vela Spila findings suggested that the inhabitants of the cave independently developed their own form of ceramic art more than 10,000 years after the Czech invention.
Tantalizing similarities thousands of years apart
The excavation revealed that ceramic art in the cave lasted for two and a half millenniums before vanishing from the archaeological record, only to reappear 8,000 years later. There are similarities between the Czech and Croatian ceramics. In each case the figurines' limbs are made by pinching each pair together to form a single appendage, as if the legs or arms are glued together. One of the Croatian figurines is covered with bands of incisions, and the artist has etched a line between the joined back legs to represent two legs, as seen in some Czech pieces.
Tantalizingly, several of the Croatian pieces feature the imprint of a finger, perhaps left behind by the artist. Again, some Czech pieces, including the Venus, have similar marks. But the Czech figurines depict feet, while the Croatian ones do not. And while the Czech ceramics were made at outdoor hearths and were sometimes deliberately exploded, as if in a ritual, the Croatian ceramics were found in a cave with no hearth.
Other archaeologists are unconvinced that the Vela Spila ceramics were a brand-new invention. Jiri Svoboda of the Institute of Archaeology of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Brno, says it is also plausible that the Croatian artists learned from the Czechs. "It seems that these people were doing very similar things but 10,000 to 15,000 years later," he said.
The archaeological record is silent so far on a question that teases the imagination: What were the ceramics for? Could they have been as mobile as their makers, perhaps carried as tokens in the clothing of those hairy mammoth hunters?