Page 2 of 2 Previous

Continued: Mercedes pleads for leniency as it answers 'Tire-gate' charges at F1 hearing in Paris

  • Article by: JOHN LEICESTER , AP Sports Writer
  • Last update: June 20, 2013 - 12:00 PM

"If we did these nefarious things to the fundamental principles (of sporting fairness) it cannot be the case that Ferrari didn't also do them," Harris said.

Howard, for the FIA, called the Ferrari test "a complete red herring." The FIA said it did look into a Pirelli tire test involving Ferrari in Barcelona in April. But FIA President Jean Todt, who worked for Ferrari from 1993 to 2009, closed that case. The FIA said the Italian team used its 2011 car for the test, which didn't violate the ban on current cars being used for track testing.

Harris, however, said 2011 and 2013 cars are very similar, the performance differences "miniscule."

"They haven't even been charged by the FIA," he said of Ferrari. "It is not fair, we respectfully suggest, to treat us in a disproportionate manner different to Ferrari. It would send completely the wrong message out to the sport and to the wider world."

Another bone of contention was whether Mercedes got prior approval for the test from the FIA. The team insisted that it did — from Charlie Whiting, a veteran FIA executive who directs the running of F1 races, backed by the FIA's legal department. Howard, however, said Whiting's opinion wasn't binding and that he wasn't the right person to authorize such a test.

Howard said none of the other F1 teams were invited to the testing and none were aware it was taking place.

"If Pirelli and Mercedes had been transparent and open about what was going on" other teams would have been able to say beforehand if they objected, he said.

Harris, for Mercedes, conceded: "We can see now with the benefit of hindsight how other teams may have become suspicions."

He acknowledged that Rosberg and Hamilton were asked to wear black helmets, masking their identity, for the testing. Mercedes now regrets that "and we apologize for that," Harris said.

"That was not the smartest move, and I can see that, and we take that on the chin."

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters