Holiday creep

Is Thanksgiving getting squeezed out?

November 8, 2011 at 8:10PM
(RITA REED/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Thanksgiving dinner with cooked turkey -- Star Tribune staff photo, early or mid-November 1994, by Rita Reed.
(STAR TRIBUNE/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Halloween was just last week. Our jack-o-lanterns are still sitting, fresh and perky, on the front step.

But it already looks a lot like Christmas, at least in Retail Land. The ghosts and ghouls and witches have vanished, replaced overnight by Santas and reindeer and angels.

What happened to Thanksgiving? Commercially, it barely exists. That was clear last weekend when my husband and I tried shopping for a care package for our college-student daughter. We'd missed Halloween, so he wanted to send her a Thanksgiving surprise -- a couple treats, something seasonal for her apartment.

joel koyama\u2022jkoyama@startribune.com weed1105 00005289a]  Window boxes at Tangletown gardens.
(DML - Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The pickings were pretty slim. No turkeys or cornucopias on candy wrappers or knickknacks. Even autumn motifs were hard to come by. After scouring three stores, we finally found one dish towel with an orange maple leaf appliqued on it.

I've always liked Thanksgiving, in large part because it WAS less commercial than the other big holidays. The focus was on family, not stuff that you buy.

But as Halloween gets bigger and glitzier, and Christmas starts earlier and earlier, it's also getting harder to savor and appreciate harvest time and Thanksgiving as their own unique holiday season.

Christmas creep and the Thanksgiving squeeze have been going on for a while. The recently departed Andy Rooney, "60 Minutes" resident curmudgeon, was grousing about it in 2002. (www.cbsnews.com/stories/2002/11/22/60minutes/rooney/main530555.shtml)

Do you think Thanksgiving gets short shrift these days? Is our rush to Christmas diluting our most American holiday?

about the writer

about the writer

kimjpalmer