•••
On Tuesday night I watched the debate with my family, as I assume millions of us did across the country. I consider myself in the “radical middle,” a term our faith community uses to describe a position not swayed by the far left or far right but that considers a value system based on brotherly love and the human flourishing of all beings. I kept an open mind about the two candidates and was looking for different key takeaways from each.
First of all, some general observations: It is not the moderators’ job to do fact-checking during the debate. I have never seen this before. A debate is between two people, and it is the responsibility of the respective debaters to dispute false information with facts of their own. There was also an advertisement run during the break that was in favor of Vice President Kamala Harris. The network has the ability to approve/deny all ads running during this time slot. This was totally uncalled for, regardless of who the sponsor was.
What I was looking for from each candidate: Could former President Donald Trump not be his own worst enemy? Not on this night. Instead of sticking to the strong talking points of the Republican Party, i.e., immigration, the economy and the wars in the Middle East, he rambled on in several instances to defend himself and his name. He missed out on connecting the dots with President Joe Biden’s failing mental health over the past several months and her knowledge of it. Instead of rising above her comments on his rallies, he defended them. A better response: “You heard it right here, folks: Harris has personally invited you to a Trump rally. Come early because the seats fill quickly — and be prepared to be energized.” Period. He was not prepared and he looked it.
Could Harris look and talk “presidential”? In my opinion, she was the clear winner of the night. It started by walking over and shaking Trump’s hand and introducing herself. She was well prepared and used facts as talking points. She stepped out from the shadow of being the vice president and projected herself as a strong presidential candidate for change. She was poised and in control and used a sharp, prosecutorial approach to keep Trump on the defensive.
The election is less than two months away, and I hope there will be additional opportunities for these two candidates to share the same stage in a debate. However, in my humble opinion, Trump was thrown a softball, given all the issues that face our country, and he whiffed. Harris was well prepared and showed the country, and the world, a different side that I haven’t seen before. Advantage Harris.
Tim Rubash, Apple Valley