For banks, what credit crunch?
- Article by: MIKE MEYERS
- Star Tribune
- November 2, 2008 - 10:36 PM
The president hectors bankers to lend. The secretary of the Treasury complains that banks are hoarding cash. The Federal Reserve chairman sounds alarms about reanimating banks in gridlock.
The nation indeed may be facing a financial crisis, with large institutions failing in the wake of multibillion debts, but most bank-lending to business customers actually has been on the rise.
"The story goes that they [banks] are holding on to the money or putting it into Treasury bills," said Lawrence Christiano, a Northwestern University economist and consultant to the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. "That seems to fly directly into the face of the evidence that's out there."
The latest government numbers, through mid-October, show bank commercial and industrial loans up, bank commercial real estate loans rising and interbank loans climbing. Indeed, from September 2007 to mid-October of this year, the numbers in all three categories have climbed consistently.
It's a puzzle that's getting little attention, even as hundreds of billions of taxpayer dollars are devoted to fixing a problem that seems belied by government figures.
"Their own data seems to contradict their position," said V.V. Chari. "It would be valuable for them to explain what they're talking about."
The $700 billion taxpayer bailout of large players in the financial system reminds Chari of the buildup to the Iraq war.
"The analogies with the war in Iraq are more than disturbing," Chari said. "We're again hearing things like: 'We know things you don't know. Trust us.'"
Federal Reserve Board and Treasury representatives declined to comment on the discrepancies between the rising lending reflected by government statistics and statements about the fragility of the banking sector made by Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson.
"Paulson said the funds stopped flowing," Christiano said. "Nobody has explained how the money system has frozen when the data says it has not."
To be sure, Federal Reserve Board figures could mask a slowdown in lending, to some degree. Major firms such as General Motors, the Tribune Co., Gannett and others have tapped huge lines of credit to ensure they will have enough cash on hand in tough times.
But Chari, Christiano and University of Minnesota economist Patrick Kehoe, in a working paper published in October, note that bank deposits actually have climbed even as commercial-paper borrowing fell precipitously in recent weeks.
"One possibility is that banks are reducing their borrowings from the commercial-paper market and substituting deposits for these borrowings," the authors wrote. "If so, it's difficult to see why this substitution should create major problems for either the financial sector or the rest of the economy."
Claims appear to be myths
Four claims about the nature of the nation's financial crisis appear to be myths, they concluded.
•Bank lending to corporate America and individuals has not declined.
•Lending between banks has not dried up.
•Commercial paper (short-term borrowing by nonfinancial companies) has fallen, but not seized up as a source of commercial lending. (Indeed, commercial-paper levels last week started to head back up for the first time since the failure of Lehman Brothers, in mid-September.)
•Banks do not, as popularly believed, play a large role in channeling money from savers to borrowers.
While no recent Minnesota banking statistics are available, the spokesman for most of the state's 438 banks said tales of bankers pulling back on commercial lending are hard to find -- at least, among the bankers.
"I've have heard nothing about them changing terms of lending," said Brad Ruiter, communications director at the Minnesota Bankers Association.
Indeed, a spot check with commercial banks across the state echoed Ruiter's observation.
"Our loan growth is up on the business side," said Steve Meads, president of Bremer Bank Twin Cities. It rose 9 percent in the third quarter, he said.
"We're scrutinizing credit requests closely," he said. "But we haven't had a dramatic change in our underwriting standards."
Commercial loan volume may go flat in the fourth quarter, Meads acknowledged.
"But the slowness is due to the economic climate," he said. "It's not due to the bank's ability to lend."
Loan was easy to obtain
Oscar Carlson, chief executive of Minneapolis-based American Spirit Graphics Corp., recently borrowed $2.75 million from Bremer to pay for new presses for his printing business. The prospect of an economic slowdown made Carlson wary of borrowing, but getting the money was no problem, he said.
"Sure, we're afraid of it," Carlson said of the prospect of an economic downturn. "But it's also a good time to expand," he said. "In many cases, you can get better prices on the equipment and on the loans, because demand for both seems to be down."
Rip Riordan, president of Vadnais-based Ambassador Communications, bought his direct-mail advertising company recently with the help of a loan of more than $1 million from Bremer. Before that transaction, the only loans he'd ever taken out were for a car and a house.
"It was painless," Riordan said of the process, which took less than three weeks. "Friends all thought that wasn't possible, based on how they were looking at trends," he said. "It wasn't based on any facts. It was based on assumptions."
Brad Bakken, president of Citizens Independent Bank, said credit demand continues unabated.
"The financial markets are where the problems are," Bakken said. "They're primarily in the subprime market, where most of our banks did not participate."
Mike Meyers • 612-673-1746
© 2015 Star Tribune