The British group Chumbawamba had a hit song with "Tubthumping" ("I get knocked down, but I get up again ...") and then -- well -- nothing, as far as the U.S. charts are concerned.
MINNESOTA'S ONE-HIT WONDERS
The Trashmen, "Surfin Bird," 1963
The Castaways, "Liar Liar," 1965
Lipps, Inc., "Funkytown," 1980
Boys Club, "I Remember Holding You," 1988
The Rembrandts, "I'll Be There for You," 1995
Jonny Lang, "Lie to Me," 1997
Semisonic, "Closing Time," 1998JON BREAM
For some, it's just one hit
- Article by: BILL WARD
- Star Tribune
- September 25, 2012 - 3:35 PM
Take a bow, Chumbawamba and the Knack. Go ahead and bask, Edie Brickell and Miley Cyrus' dad, whatever your name is.
Yes, today is One Hit Wonder Day, perhaps the only "Hallmark holiday" in which the honorees are denigrated as much as celebrated, victims of that peculiar human tendency to put folks on a pedestal and relish knocking them down.
As if any of us could make a song -- just one -- embraced by millions.
"It's a huge deal," said Chris Osgood, veteran local musician and music instructor at McNally Smith College of Music. Osgood, who still plays and sings with local punk-rock pioneers the Suicide Commandos, said he has lost count of "all the bands I see and get to know that are touring the country based on one song." He also pointed out that Steven Greenberg has made a cottage industry of "Funkytown," the mega-hit he recorded here with David Z as Lipps, Inc.
Basically, while the song's limelight time might be fleeting, the artist's talent is not (well, OK, there's Vanilla Ice).
"I look at the one-hit wonder as someone whose talent found an outlet for a brief period of time," said Andy Scheiber, chair of the University of St. Thomas' English department and a longtime musician. "The cliché is the overnight sensation who's been playing for 10 years. There is no shortage of talent, just a shortage of venues and channels for that talent.
"You cannot win if you do not play. But those who persist at it day after day, year after year, if they're good at their craft, well, it's amazing how much your luck increases if you go at it every day."
And when talent and pluck meet the right song, the artists have their day. Most, of course, never get there. As Osgood noted, "the difference between zero and one is enormous."
Bill Ward • 612-673-7643
© 2017 Star Tribune