Editorial: The real madness is 'one-and-done' title

  • Updated: April 4, 2012 - 9:07 PM

Kentucky's NCAA win spotlights hypocrisy in college sports.

hide

The Kentucky team mobs coach John Calipari after being awarded the championship trophy following a 67-59 win over Kansas on Monday.

Photo: John Sleezer, MCT

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Big-time college sports are totally corrupt. Oh, by the way, what time does the game start?

Monday night's NCAA basketball championship game started at 8:23, and over the next two and a half hours the corruption got so bad that we couldn't take our eyes off it. The University of Kentucky had placed more raw basketball talent on the court than any finalist had probably ever assembled. The Wildcats started three freshmen and two sophomores who played more like pros than college kids. And when it was all over, when the coach and "student athletes" were seated at the postgame news conference, no one asked our favorite fantasy question: "What's your favorite class?"

That's because everybody knows about the charade. These young stars weren't really college kids in the sense that their goal was to get degrees. Their brief stop in Lexington was aimed at winning a national title and moving on to the truckloads of money that await them in the NBA. (As many as six Kentucky players are expected to be first-round picks in the NBA's June draft.) They enrolled not so much at a university as in a "program," which is how the elite athletic schools now describe their basketball and football teams.

The schools strike a bargain of sorts with the most talented young players: Come to our campus for a year or two. We'll exploit and make millions of dollars off of you, and in exchange we'll showcase your talent on the national stage so you can pursue your professional dreams.

The strength of this cynical arrangement is obvious: People love it.

Who could not marvel at Monday's action: the above-the-rim acrobatics, the deft shooting touches, the brute physical strength and hustle, the symphonic teamwork, the courageous comeback by another storied program, Kansas, that fell just short? From the White House to the corner bar, March Madness and the Final Four have become a springtime obsession because it's so exciting -- and because it makes so much money.

The tournament generated an estimated $800 million for the NCAA, its member schools and various vendors, according to columnist Joe Nocera, who has written a string of scathing commentaries for the New York Times on the hypocrisy of big-time college sports. As performers in a $6 billion college football and basketball industry, the players, many of them from disadvantaged backgrounds, deserve more than just free tuition, campus glory and a chance at the NBA, he says. They should get real salaries, he says, as well as agents, a union, and other benefits that befit their status and value.

Nocera regrets the obvious overcommercialization of college football and men's basketball. But he can't abide the NCAA's dishonesty of protecting the "purity" of amateur sports while pocketing all that money.

This page doesn't quarrel with Nocera's observations or even his conclusions. We're just not yet ready to invite onto college campuses the bidding wars, holdouts, lockouts, players' strikes, free-agency negotiations, trading deadlines and all of the other sideshows that go along with professional sports.

Real student-athletes may no longer drive the big-revenue sports, but they haven't totally disappeared. North Carolina's Tyler Zeller, Wisconsin's Jordan Taylor, Ohio State's William Buford, Purdue's Robbie Hummel and Michigan State's Draymond Green are among the nation's top players who are also, by all accounts, solid students and soon-to-be college graduates. Indeed, NCAA rules (and penalties) strongly encourage teams to stock their rosters with players -- alas, usually bench players -- who are likely to graduate.

In the best of all worlds, the NBA and NFL would have minor leagues like those in baseball, and the colleges would be "stuck" with more real students who also want to play sports. Too bad we don't live in that world. Truth is, people don't want to confront the contradictions that are so obvious in college sports; they don't want sanity messing with their March Madness.

Maybe the best we can do for now is to adopt the transparent approach of John Calipari, the Kentucky coach. He makes no apologies for what he does. He recruits players who plan to turn pro after a year or two and doesn't pretend that he expects them to graduate. In that sense, Calipari is being more honest about college basketball than is the NCAA.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

  • about opinion

  • The Opinion section is produced by the Editorial Department to foster discussion about key issues. The Editorial Board represents the institutional voice of the Star Tribune and operates independently of the newsroom.

  • Submit a letter or commentary
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close