Anti-gay culture in pro sports: You can't hide the truth

  • Article by: HUDSON TAYLOR
  • Updated: July 19, 2014 - 8:36 AM

Major League Baseball has made its move. Now it’s time for pro football’s teachable moment concerning LGBT bias.

hide

Former Minnesota Vikings punter Chris Kluwe, right, speaks during a press conference, Tuesday, July 15, 2014 in Minneapolis, Minn. Kluwe intends to sue the team over allegations of anti-gay conduct by a coach, his lawyer said.

Photo: Elizabeth Flores • Star Tribune,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

On a great day this week for Major League Baseball — a sport sometimes criticized for dragging its feet — the league embraced its gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community in a meaningful, very public way during an All-Star Game news conference led by Commissioner Bud Selig in Minneapolis. In another part of town, Chris Kluwe articulated just how far the National Football League still must go in creating a welcoming and inclusive culture.

At a news conference, Kluwe and his lawyer, Clayton Halunen, explained that the Minnesota Vikings have not fulfilled their promise to release the results of an internal investigation into Kluwe’s claims about homophobic statements made by assistant coach Mike Priefer. We hear troubling reports that the Vikings seem to think publishing the results is not necessary because they already have taken internal measures to improve their clubhouse culture. (The Vikings did release the findings of their investigation Friday night.)

In these two stories, we learn that the truth can’t be hidden. Only with an open and explicit public dialogue about complex issues does society move the ball forward for an LGBT community that has been inexcusably marginalized and discriminated against. Baseball realizes this now, while football is still struggling to demonstrate the leadership it can and should provide.

Here’s what we do know: Kluwe was correct in his decision to report his coach’s homophobic tirade, and he demonstrated the kind of leadership that I hope the wrestlers I coach would emulate.

Let’s be clear: The National Football League is not anti-gay. Michael Sam is testimony to that fact. And years before Sam became the first openly gay player drafted by an NFL team, the NFL, like other professional sports leagues, added a sexual orientation nondiscrimination clause to its collective-bargaining agreement. The NFL posts its anti-discrimination code in every locker room. These are fundamental, concrete steps that meaningfully advocate inclusion and respect.

Yet when it comes to discrimination, there’s a difference between doctrine and culture. Even with anti-discrimination measures in place, sports leagues are living, breathing organisms, composed of teams with players and personnel from all different backgrounds, demographics, generations, faiths and perspectives. After formal impediments to equality are eliminated, informal bias persists via deeply ingrained cultural norms and behaviors.

As Kluwe has said, some players are hesitant to proactively support equality out of concern that they will be labeled a distraction or lose favor with team management, coaches and fans. Trying to bury information about Priefer’s alleged behavior serves only to reinforce a culture of expected attitudes and highlights the importance of having out LGBT athletes and their allies in sports.

There are clear parallels between the quest for gay inclusion in professional men’s sports and the battle for equal access and fair treatment by female sports reporters. When writer Lisa Olson dared to speak out in the 1990s about the sexual harassment she endured from Zeke Mowatt and other players in the New England Patriots locker room, she was vilified by fans and lambasted by then-Patriots owner Victor Kiam. But a thorough league investigation concluded that Olson was, in fact, “degraded and humiliated.” Mowatt and two others were fined. The team was fined, as well, and the general manager was fired.

Olson was the first to stand up and speak out against the treatment that women reporters had been routinely subjected to in a culture that looked the other way or failed to recognize the damage being inflicted. She advanced the cause for all female reporters. She also provided a teachable moment for the men of the NFL about what not to say and what not to do. Now, a generation later, we have a new teachable moment.

At great personal risk, Kluwe evaluated his situation and took action. We don’t know if there was a gay player on the team at the time, but Kluwe recognized that even though he wasn’t the target of Priefer’s words, he was in a position to expose them and to help change them. A professional athlete has spoken out and declared that he found the biases against LGBT people in his clubhouse to be so egregious that he could not in good conscience remain silent. We urge the Vikings to do the right thing and release the report publicly, to give us all an opportunity to learn how to be better allies.

Kluwe personifies allyship. His is the kind of allyship that defined Pee Wee Reese generations ago when he helped to combat racism after Jackie Robinson broke Major League Baseball’s color barrier. It is the kind of allyship that failed to emerge for Lisa Olson when she fought her battle against sexism in the NFL by herself. Kluwe’s allyship has defined him now as an example of what real leadership is about, what sportsmanship is about. If nothing else, let us hope this story encourages more athletes, at every level of play, to follow Kluwe’s example, to demonstrate their allyship and to end discrimination in sports.

Burying a report can’t silence that call to arms.

 

Hudson Taylor is the executive director of Athlete Ally, a national organization devoted to changing the culture in sports as it relates to the LGBT community.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

  • about opinion

  • The Opinion section is produced by the Editorial Department to foster discussion about key issues. The Editorial Board represents the institutional voice of the Star Tribune and operates independently of the newsroom.

  • Submit a letter or commentary
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should Roger Goodell lose his job as NFL commissioner over Rice case?

Weekly Question
 
Close