Minneapolis confronts the economics of green homes

  • Article by: MAYA RAO
  • Updated: March 21, 2014 - 12:44 PM

City’s goal to build 100 energy-efficient homes in north Minneapolis has hit delays, and sales don’t cover costs.


The city requires developers to equip the homes with solar panels, but U Prof. Lucas Alm said, “that’s actually the more bling piece of it.”

Photo: RENÉE JONES SCHNEIDER • reneejones@startribune.com,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

The new red house on 31st Avenue N. is designed to use only as much energy as it produces, a first of its kind in the Twin Cities.

More commonly seen in Europe, the so-called net zero house in north Minneapolis will save new owners Sarah Olson and Abdi Mohamed a lot of money on utility bills.

But it has also cost the city $25,000 because it sold for less than it cost to build.

Two years after Minneapolis announced plans to build 100 green homes to revive empty lots in foreclosure-battered neighborhoods, the city is confronting the reality of the market. The project, aimed at low- and middle-income earners, is as dependent as ever on government subsidies to continue. The city has approved about $2.9 million for it so far.

The City Council approved a third round of green homes this month, though many of the first- and second-round homes are not yet finished as planned for the end of 2013.

“It’s very difficult to replicate because of the cost of building green,” said Cherie Shoquist, who coordinates the project for the city. “Not just building green but building green homes of these value in distressed markets is just not cost-effective.”

She added that the city is hoping to get more private developers involved and reduce the government subsidies needed to keep the project moving ahead.

Green affordable housing is gaining interest nationally, but those efforts often focus on multifamily housing because it is more economical.

Minneapolis pursued a different strategy, guided in part by celebrity Brad Pitt’s work in New Orleans, where a nonprofit he cofounded has been building 150 energy-efficient homes in a neighborhood devastated by Hurricane Katrina.

In the wake of the North Side’s foreclosure crisis and May 2011 tornado, then-Mayor R.T. Rybak announced Green Homes North at his state of the city speech in 2012 as a project that would revitalize vacant lots where houses in disrepair had been demolished.

Since then, Minneapolis has approved 47 homes in all by nine developers, seven of which are nonprofit.

The city said the first two rounds — encompassing 27 houses — would be done by the end of last year, but weather and other factors delayed their completion. The project is also taking longer than expected as the city tries to meet its goals to hire women and minorities for the construction.

The development gap

Home buyers have moved into at least four houses during recent months, and developers are closing sales on others. The rest of the 27 homes are expected to be occupied by summer, with everyone from working artists to large families. Sales prices will range from $150,000 to $250,000.

Only about half of the costs approved by the City Council come from the city’s own coffers; the rest is contributed from the Minnesota Housing Finance Agency and the nonprofit Family Housing Fund. The homes are to be sold to people earning up to 15 percent above the region’s median income, with a limit of $96,500 for a family of four.

The city requires developers to make the homes “solar ready” so that homeowners can later choose to install such technology on their own. They are also supposed to build in more insulation than what is usually used and monitor energy performance after owners move in.

Though the program was also part of a broader vision to rebuild north Minneapolis’ dropping population, one of the new homeowners moved in from another house he owned down the block. Robert Smith, a single professor at St. Olaf College, was drawn to the environmentally friendly features and bought a three-bedroom green home developed by Peyser LLC, one of the few private developers involved in the city program, for just more than $200,000 on the 3800 block of Sheridan Avenue N.

  • related content

  • Sarah Olson and her family moved into this net zero house in north Minneapolis after helping Habitat for Humanity build the home. It was designed by students and staff of the University of Minnesota to generate as much power as it uses.

  • Sarah Olson pointed out the solar drain back tank in a closet of her net zero house in Minneapolis, which has extra thick insulation in the walls and triple-pane glass windows. Thermostats on separate floors also help save energy.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters