Two Rochester women get 10, 20 years for aiding Somalia terrorists

  • Article by: RANDY FURST , Star Tribune
  • Updated: May 17, 2013 - 10:06 AM

One got 10 years in prison, the other 20 for funneling money to a group fighting in Somalia.

 

Two Rochester women were sentenced to federal prison Thursday for their roles in funneling money to an organization the U.S. government has called a terrorist group fighting in Somalia.

Hawo Mohamed Hassan, 66, who got 10 years in prison, and Amina Farah Ali, 36, who got 20, were the last of nine people sentenced in federal court in Minneapolis this week.

The group was the first set of defendants sent to prison from Minneapolis in this country’s largest anti-terrorism investigation since Sept. 11, 2001.

U.S. Chief Judge Michael Davis handed down the sentences before a courtroom packed with the defendants’ families and members of the Somali-American community.

The drama capped a federal investigation that lasted more than four years in which U.S. authorities sought to shut down a recruiting effort that lured more than 20 young men to Somalia, several of whom died fighting or in suicide bombings.

The women, both U.S. citizens who came here from Somalia, were convicted in 2011 of conspiring to provide material support to Al-Shabab in fundraising in Rochester that prosecutors have called “a deadly pipeline” of money and fighters from the United State to Somalia.

They have had wide support in the Twin Cities’ Somali-American community, and many in the courtroom were stunned by the sentences, especially the 20-year sentence for Ali.

Hassan Mohamud, a St. Paul imam, said he believes the sentences were too long and that both women should have been released.

“All they did was aid the poor and the orphans,” he said.

But prosecutors said it was clear from the phone conversations they monitored that the women knew they were raising money for Al-Shabab, a group labeled a terrorist organization by the U.S. State Department in 2008.

While Ali said she never knew that funds she raised were going to Al-Shabab, Hassan claimed that she came to realize the organization was getting the money and broke with Ali, preferring that the money go to set up a senior health center.

But prosecutor Jeff Paulsen cited telephone wiretaps that he said showed there had been no rift between the two and that Hassan had a financial investment in the health center and planned to continue to work with Ali.

Ali, sentenced first, denied she did anything wrong. She said she had no knowledge that the money she collected went to Al-Shabab.

Asked by Davis what she knew about Al-Qajda, she indicated she knew nothing about it.

Her attorney, Dan Scott, said “she chose the wrong horse,” adding, “She thought she was doing good work. She was wrong.”

Defendants in the Somali cases have argued that Ethiopia invaded Somalia to support a newly created transitional government that lacked support from the Somali people. They have said that their clients backed the resistance to the invasion.

However, prosecutors argued that the transitional government was recognized by foreign nations, so any support for Al-Shabab, which was fighting the invasion, was against U.S. law as well as support for a terrorist group.

Steven Ward, who prosecuted the case, said Ali was heard on a wiretap supporting Al-Shabab, saying she supported a suicide bombing and “let the civilians die.”

At Hassan’s sentencing, her attorney, Randy Daar said that in hindsight, she realized that Al-Shabab “has done terrible things.”

He said his client’s mother was raped and killed, dying in her daughter’s arms, and that her activity could be linked to post-traumatic stress syndrome.

But Paulsen said any PTSD link was unsubstantiated.

Also Thursday, Abdarus Abdulle Ali, 29, was given two years for lying to a grand jury.

The Columbia Heights man had pleaded guilty in 2009 to lying to a grand jury about meetings he attended and money he contributed in support of Al-Shabab.

 

Randy Furst • 612-673-4224

 

  • related content

  • Video: Supporters decry 20-year sentence for Somali woman

    Thursday May 16, 2013

    Community members and supporters reacted with shock and outrage after Amina Farah Ali of Rochester was sentenced to 20...

  • Photo gallery: Supporters of Somali women gather outside federal courthouse

    Friday May 17, 2013

    Supporters of two Rochester women who were sentenced to federal prison Thursday gathered outside the federal courthouse in Minneapolis...

  • The two women sentenced for raising money for Al-Shabab had a number of supporters at the federal courthouse in Minneapolis.)

  • Hawo Mohamed Hassan, left, and Amina Farah Ali entering the federal courthouse during their 2011 trial.

  • Supporters of the two Rochester women who were sentenced to federal prison for raising money for Al-Shabab in Somalia said afternoon prayers outside the courtroom on the federal courthouse plaza in Minneapolis on Thursday.

  • The two Rochester women convicted of raising money for Al-Shabab were...

  • timeline

    June 2006: Islamic Courts Union (ICU) of which Al-Shabab is an entity, takes control of Mogadishu, Somalia

    December 2006: Ethiopia invades Somalia, invited by the Somali Transitional Federal Government, prosecutors say. Others say invasion had U.S. backing to overthrow ICU.

    More than 1,000 Somalis rally in Minneapolis to call for immediate Ethiopian withdrawal.

    Mid 2007: ICU dismantled, Al-Shabab influence grows.

    December 2007: The first of about 20 young men leave Minneapolis and travel to Somalia to train and fight with Al-Shabab.

    February 2008: Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice designates Al-Shabab a terrorist organization.

    October 2008: Shirwa Ahmed, 26, of Minneapolis, dies in a car-bombing in Somalia. He is believed to be the first American suicide bomber.

    June-July 2009: Three Minneapolis men killed in Mogadishu.

    July 2009: Two Somali men with local ties are the first to be indicted on a charge of aiding terrorism.

    September 2009: A fifth Somali man from Minneapolis and a Muslim convert from Minneapolis are killed in Mogadishu.

    June 20, 2011: Number of men charged in Minnesota with supporting terrorism reaches 20.

    Oct. 20, 2011: Two Rochester women are convicted of conspiring to provide support to a foreign terrorist group but weren’t connected to the recruitment of fighters.

    Oct. 18, 2012: One-time mosque janitor Mahamud Said Omar found guilty of five terror-related charges.

    May. 13-16, 2013: U.S. Chief Judge Michael Davis to sentence nine people.

    the sentences

    Amina Farah Ali

    Rochester

    20 years: She collected money from fundraisers for the needy in Somalia and funneled some of it to Al-Shabab.

    Hawo Mohamed Hassa Rochester

    10 years: She helped collect money for the needy in Somalia and funneled some of it to Al-Shabab.

    Mahamud Said Omar

    Minneapolis

    20 years: A former mosque janitor who helped arrange travel of young men to Somalia to fight, went to Somalia himself and provided cash for rifles.

    Omer Abdi Mohamed

    Minneapolis

    12 years: A “middleman” who helped send young men from Minneapolis to Somalia.

    Kamal Said Hassan

    Minneapolis

    10 years: He went to Somalia to fight and helped Al-Shabab make an English-language recruiting video. His sentence was reduced because of his “extraordinary cooperation” with the investigation.

    Abdifatah Yusuf Isse

    Minneapolis

    3 years: He went to Somalia to fight and earned a reduced sentence by cooperating with the investigation.

    Salah Osman Ahmed

    Brooklyn Park

    3 years: He traveled to Somalia and trained with Al-Shabab. He also cooperated with the investigation.

    Ahmed Hussein Mahamud

    Westerville, Ohio (formerly) of Eden Prairie

    3 years: He raised up to $1,500 to send recruits to Somalia.

    Abdarus Abudulle Ali

    Columbia Heights

    2 years: He attended meetings and gave money in support of Al-Shabab.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Is Paul Molitor the best choice to be the next Twins manager?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close