From across the pond, a view of America and its guns

Violence is a product of the Constitution and frontier psychology.

February 24, 2018 at 12:38AM
The U.S. is awash with weapons. To some they are a persistent danger, to others a constitutionally protected way of life. What must be painfully obvious to all is that they part of a culture of violence that desperately needs to be addressed.

There's a tendency in Britain to ask "why not just ban all firearms"?

For good or ill, the freedom to bear arms is guaranteed in the U.S. Constitution, and some Americans are so enthusiastic about exercising this right that it's estimated there are now more guns than people. Ban guns, say the lobbyists, and only the innocent will obey the law, putting them at the mercy of armed criminals.

Why not regulate guns to limit firepower and cease sales to those who should not have them? Some regulation is ineffectual: Several killers passed background checks and owned their guns legally. Efforts in Congress to go further have repeatedly fallen afoul of partisanship.

Pro-gun activists are held up as heartless villains, but such a narrow apportion of blame ignores the complexities. The U.S. is shaped by a centuries-old frontier psychology. Its welfare system offers scant help to the mentally ill. Its schools are depersonalizing. Its young are prey to fantasies of empowerment through violence.

When Al Gore, then vice president, spoke in the wake of the 1999 Columbine High School massacre, which seemed to open this historic cycle of violence, he cut across the partisan divide by addressing both gun control and the importance of fostering character: "We must replace a culture of violence and mayhem with one of values and meaning."

Success implementing this in the years that followed has been negligible. The Trump administration has promised action to enforce the law, which hopefully begins a long, hard journey that America needs to take.

FROM AN EDITORIAL IN THE TELEGRAPH OF LONDON

about the writer

about the writer

Editorial, Telegraph of London

More from Commentaries

See More
card image
Renée Jones Schneider/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Over time it has been one of the most effective such offices in the nation, but recently it has been seriously diminished.

card image
card image