To be, or not to be, free? Museums ponder vexing question

  • Article by: MARY ABBE , Star Tribune
  • Updated: April 30, 2014 - 1:02 PM

That is the question vexing museums around the country as they seek to attract new visitors.

Full Screen view larger

A family of four visiting the Science Museum of Minnesota could spend nearly $50 just to get in the door. But a drop-in at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts (MIA) would cost them nothing. What’s up with that?

It’s not that dinosaur bones cost more than Monet paintings.

Museum admission fees vary wildly for all sorts of reasons and, not surprisingly, they’re a hot topic in the field. History, institutional psychology and other factors come into play in deciding about how much, if anything, to charge. Most museums rely on a mix of endowment income, government funding and corporate and private donations to cover their basic costs. Admission fees fill in where those sources fall short. And many places that offer free admission, including the MIA, tack on charges for special shows.

The institute, which dropped general admission fees 25 years ago, was a pioneer in the “free” museum camp, although it’s not alone. Many museums in Washington, D.C., are free, as are the Dallas Museum of Art, the Cincinnati Art Museum and the Kimbell Art Museum in Fort Worth, Texas.

Elsewhere, however, hefty fees are common. In San Francisco, the Exploratorium science center charges $25 for adults. New York’s Museum of Modern Art also charges $25, while the Metropolitan Museum of Art “recommends” entry donations of that amount. In Chicago, the Art Institute charges adults $23, and the Field Museum charges $18.

“I’d never worked for a free museum before I came here and always thought you have to charge because people value what they pay for,” said Kaywin Feldman, the MIA’s executive director since 2008. “But I’ve completely changed my mind and now think that you have to be free to be accessible.”

The MIA’s policy is deeply rooted. When the museum opened in 1915, its bylaws required it to be “free of charge” at least three days per week including Sundays. A special Hennepin County tax was even set up to help cover its operating costs. That fund last year generated $10.9 million, or more than one-third of the museum’s budget.

To ensure access regardless of income, most museums ­have regular free days or evenings. And virtually all of them offer discounts to children, students, senior citizens and people who have bought a museum membership.

Dallas freebies

Dallas Museum of Art director Maxwell Anderson became a provocative advocate of the free policy when he abolished that institution’s admission charges in 2013 and followed up with free membership in 2014.

He argues that counting on admission fees to balance budgets warps priorities by prompting museums to overbuild their facilities and book commercially appealing shows designed to boost ticket sales rather than to enrich cultural appreciation. Such tactics may work in big, tourist-heavy cities such as New York and Los Angeles, he observed, but often disappoint in the heartland.

Memberships also may intimidate the uninitiated, he said.

“If you’re a new visitor unaccustomed to museums and someone asks if you’re a member, that’s not very welcoming and makes it seem as if we’re a club,” Anderson said in a recent interview. “We museums look like banks or fancy clubs. We’re forbidding and intimidating to the public who don’t regularly go to museums. So this is a way of calling the question on the economic model we’ve all been espousing for a generation and that I think is broken.”

Dallas museumgoers who sign up for a free membership earn perks by taking tours, “liking” their favorite art works on social media and participating in other programs. Perks range from free parking and shop discounts to an overnight stay in the museum or lunch with the director.

More than 60,000 people have joined for free in the past year, and an additional 15,000 signed on to a “partners” program for which they pay an average of about $330 annually. That generated $3.6 million for the museum in 2013, just a bit below the $3.9 million it took in from 19,000 traditional members the previous year. Most important, the 75,000 members offer gold mines of data about their taste in art, food, shopping and more.

The MIA, along with museums in Denver and Los Angeles, will try some of these ideas over the next two years thanks to a $450,000 grant.

Paying to play

Like the MIA, the Science Museum in St. Paul relies on various “revenue streams” to cover its $40 million annual budget. It gets $1.2 million in state funding but counts on admission tickets to cover a substantial chunk of operating costs. It charges $12 for regular adult gallery admission and up to $28 for special shows with Imax movie features, such as its current “Ultimate Dinosaurs” exhibit.

  • related content

  • Free days at Twin Cities museums

    Wednesday April 30, 2014

    On certain days, adults can catch a break at these museums, which charge for admission but typically offer discounts to youngsters, students and seniors, and to paid members.

  • A visitor gazed at “Santos Dumont — The Father of Aviation II” by Kehinde Wiley at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts, which was a trailblazer when it dropped general admission fees 25 years ago.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters