U.S. Bank paid only $220 million for stadium naming rights? ("New Vikings stadium will be named for U.S. Bank in 20-year agreement," June 16.) Chump change! We paid over twice that. So why isn't it being called the "Minnesota Taxpayers' Stadium?"
Gus Fenton, Minneapolis
• • •
On, no! We suddenly have two football stadiums named "Bank." How will we ever keep them straight? Perhaps we could take a page from the Metropolitan Airports Commission and call them "Bank 1" and "Bank 2"?
James Berry, Edina
Q COMP
Research has too found that it produced gains in achievement
It's a good thing Steve Watson's June 16 commentary on Q Comp ("The state of Q Comp, 10 years in") was in the Opinion Exchange, because that's all it was — his opinion. Had Watson actually tried to find an independent evaluation of Q Comp's impact, he would have found one from 2013 by researchers from the University of Minnesota and St. Catherine University. In regard to student achievement, the researchers found: "Q Comp's teacher-pay reforms produced an average three percent of a standard deviation increase in reading achievement, with some evidence of a similar effect on math achievement … ." In addition, they found Q Comp's benefits for teachers were strongest for newer teachers. In all, they concluded Q Comp may have a 5-to-1 benefit-to-cost ratio.
The Q Comp program certainly can be strengthened — to create a stronger link between a teacher's performance and his or her compensation (rather than relying on simple salary schedules). Moving forward, hopefully, we can rely on evidence rather than opinion.
Jim Bartholomew, Edina
The writer is education policy director of the Minnesota Business Partnership.
GARBAGE HAULING
The majority of us know enough to appreciate a free market
Congratulations to the author of "Addressing problems together" (Readers Write, June 13). His government indoctrination regarding garbage hauling is complete.
A few facts for him: 70 percent of Minnesota cities have open hauling. The government controls the final destination of garbage. Regardless of garbage system, most cities maintain a 35- to 50-year road-replacement cycle. The hauling industry has taken it upon itself to reduce its effect on the environment by operating lighter-weight trucks with compressed natural gas for fuel.