Duane Benson, a Minnesota farmer who served as a popular Republican state senator, business lobbyist and, until last year, director of the Minnesota Early Learning Foundation (MELF), is miffed with hard-right conservatives within the majority Republican caucus in the Minnesota House.
"Put a jersey on these guys so we can tell what team they're on," said an irritated Benson. "I thought they wanted value for tax dollars."
MELF spent several years and $20 million in private dollars, overseen by business backers, early-education specialists from the University of Minnesota and preschool providers, to develop "Parent Aware," a rating system for preschools. The system included education for providers to achieve best-practice standards and a good rating. The idea is to get more value from the same $400 million in government subsidies for preschool education in Minnesota.
Economists at the Minneapolis Federal Reserve Bank have estimated that the best public investment we can make is getting kids ready for kindergarten. It's estimated that half of Minnesota's kids struggle from the get-go, have a higher high school dropout rate and get in trouble, and that leads to millions in public costs.
Gov. Mark Dayton and the minority DFL caucus, which has embraced the business-backed preschool reforms, is trying to get $2 million in scholarship money through the Legislature that would go as $4,000 scholarships for low-income kids to Parent Aware-rated providers.
Rep. Sondra Erickson, a Republican, last week effectively untied the money from the Parent Aware rating system with amendments that passed the House along partisan lines that would allow the subsidy to also go to unrated, in-home or other providers. A related bill is moving through the Senate with bipartisan support
House Speaker Kurt Zellers did not respond last week to inquiries about whether the top Republican supports the business-backed early-learning reforms. Some of the conservative opponents have argued that the MELF reforms only further the "nanny state" and prefer home-based preschool.
The Minnesota Chamber of Commerce, the Minnesota Business Partnership, MELF -- now called Parent Aware for School Readiness -- all support the initiative.