It's a challenge to update a tired office building's public spaces. Three new examples in downtown Minneapolis show what's new, what's possible and how modern design is still working its way through a phase you might call "playful incoherence."
Consider first the atrium at 121 S. 8th St., the old TCF Bank building. When it opened in the early 1970s, it had a cafe, an aquarium, splashing water, warmth in the winter, light from the big skylight. It was something you'd show an out-of-town guest on the way to more interesting downtown spots.
By the time it closed two years ago, the atrium was an empty, dead space, a graveyard for every '70s mistake. Ugly brick. Dated circular patterns on the floor. Flabby arches above, a joyless fountain below, a verdigris copper piece of art that looked like a virus in various stages of mutation.
How to make it look better?
Option 1: Fill it with concrete and just walk away.
Option 2: Fill it with water and add synchronized swimmers.
Option 3: Paint it white and fill the space with a massive staircase that would make Busby Berkeley think "Now that's a bit much."
Ryan, the company that revived the old building, chose Option 3.