Advertisement

The Junk Drawer: Don't give in to whining

Your 5-year-old has a renewed penchant for whining since starting kindergarten. What gives?

February 19, 2011 at 9:18PM

Don't give in to your kid's whining ways -- or elseYour 5-year-old has a renewed penchant for whining since starting kindergarten. What gives?

"Most whiners are made and not born," says Brett Berk, early childhood expert and author of "The Gay Uncle's Guide to Parenting" (Random House, $14).

But school isn't doing the making.

"If you have a whiner, it's probably at least partly your fault," he contends. "But it's never too late to change patterns or prevent new ones from taking root."

Here's the approach you should take, according to Berk:

"When your child whines -- especially when the whine is attached to a question, request or demand -- simply remind them calmly to speak to you in a regular voice.

"If they continue to whine, repeat your admonishment and then ignore them until they abide."

Here's the biggie: "Do not ever, under any circumstance, give in to whining," he says. "If you do, your child will quickly come to believe this is an appropriate and effective means to get what they want, and I guarantee that you will have signed yourself -- and anyone within earshot -- up for a lifelong tasting in your child's extensive whine cellar."

Advertisement
Advertisement

CHICAGO TRIBUNE

Head-banging is the issueQ Our first child, a 10-month-old boy, bangs his head on the headboard of his crib when we put him to bed. He doesn't cry, but he pushes himself to his hands and knees and then begins rocking forward and backward, banging his head in the process. I'm very worried, although in all other respects, he acts normally. Can it be stopped?

A Aggressive, injurious head-banging is associated with certain profound forms of mental and emotional disability, but happy, healthy infants have been known to gently "bang" their heads as a means of relaxation. What your son is doing to put himself to sleep is what's called "nonpathological head-banging." Consider it the physical equivalent of counting sheep. He should certainly be allowed to keep rocking.

JOHN ROSEMOND, FAMILY PSYCHOLOGIST

Charlotte (N.C.) Observer

about the writer

about the writer

More from No Section

See More
Advertisement
Advertisement

To leave a comment, .

Advertisement