Kansas judge throws out machine gun possession charge, cites Second Amendment

A federal judge in Kansas has tossed out a machine gun possession charge and questioned if bans on the weapons violate the Second Amendment.

If upheld on appeal, the ruling by U.S. District Judge John W. Broomes in Wichita could have a sweeping impact on the regulation of machine guns, including homemade automatic weapons that many police and prosecutors blame for fueling gun violence.

Broomes, an appointee of President Donald Trump, on Wednesday dismissed two machine gun possession counts against Tamori Morgan, who was indicted last year. Morgan was accused of possessing a model AM-15 .300-caliber machine gun and a machine gun conversion device known as a ''Glock switch'' that can make a semi-automatic weapon fire like a machine gun.

''The court finds that the Second Amendment applies to the weapons charged because they are ‘bearable arms' within the original meaning of the amendment,'' Broomes wrote. He added that the government ''has the burden to show that the regulation is consistent with this nation's historical firearm regulation tradition.''

As of Friday, no appeal had been filed. A spokeswoman for the U.S. Attorney's Office in Wichita declined comment.

Federal prosecutors in the case said in earlier court filings that the ''Supreme Court has made clear that regulations of machineguns fall outside the Second Amendment.''

A June 2022 Supreme Court ruling in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen was seen as a major expansion of gun rights. The ruling said Americans have a right to carry firearms in public for self-defense.

''It gives lower court judges the ability to pick and choose the historical record in a way that they think the Second Amendment should be read,'' Charles said.

Charles expects Broomes' ruling to be overturned, citing Supreme Court precedent allowing for regulation of machine guns.

Eric Ruben, a fellow at the Brennan Center and an associate law professor of Southern Methodist University, agreed.

''As far as I know, this is the first time in American history that a machine gun ban has been found unconstitutional in its application,'' Ruben said.

Shira Feldman of Brady United Against Gun Violence, called the ruling ''an incredibly dangerous decision, and it's inconsistent with what the Supreme Court has said the Second Amendment means.''

Communities across the U.S. have dealt with a surge of shootings carried out with weapons converted to fully automatic in recent years. These weapons are typically converted using small pieces of metal made with a 3D printer or ordered online.

Guns with conversion devices have been used in several mass shootings, including one that left four dead at a Sweet Sixteen party in Alabama last year and another that left six people dead in a bar district in Sacramento, California, in 2022. In Houston, police officer William Jeffrey died in 2021 after being shot with a converted gun while serving a warrant.