NFL playoffs: Meet the 14 QBs who didn't get their coaches fired — for now

On the NFL Insider: The 14 playoff teams have 14 different situations at quarterback — some meticulously planned, some stopgaps and some Band-Aids.

January 13, 2024 at 12:38AM
On Saturday, 22-year-old rookie first-round pick C.J. Stroud of the Texans will face soon-to-be-39 Joey Flacco, who was Cleveland’s fourth starting quarterback this season. (Associated Press photos/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Kevin O'Connell fell short of reaching the NFL's Super Wild-Card Weekend, but he sure is rising on the NFL's list of Coaches Who Have Not Been Fired … For Now.

The Vikings hired O'Connell into this 32-person fraternity 23 months ago. Today, he's the NFL's 17th-longest-tenured coach.

That's how quickly things happen in a league that now has decided to change coaches 42 times since 2019, including eight this year.

As young KO is learning all too well, staying on the longevity list requires one of two things: 1. Finding the right situation at quarterback, or 2. Finding a way to win without the right situation at quarterback.

The first one is difficult. The second one is darn near impossible because, well, it's tough being a genius — or even the G.O.A.T. — without the right situation at quarterback.

Ask Bill Belichick. The only difference between his dismissal after four Tom Brady-free seasons and everyone else's is Bill got to announce his firing as a "mutual decision." Yeah, right.

Saturday starts the NFL's 12-game, 33-day postseason festival en route to the Super Bowl LVIII champion being crowned Feb. 11 in Las Vegas. The 14 qualifiers have 14 different situations at quarterback — some of them healthy for years to come, some of them stopgaps and some of them Band-Aids that teams are hoping stick for another 33 days.

The field features six teams — Lions, Packers, Rams, Browns, Texans and Steelers — that are newbies to the party this year. That means the NFL has gone 34 straight seasons with at least four faces in the postseason who weren't there the year before.

There also are four new division winners: Lions, Cowboys, Ravens and Texans. Houston went from worst to first in the AFC South, making it 19 of the past 21 years with at least one worst-to-first division winner.

The different paths to the right quarterback are no more starkly displayed than what's sitting atop each conference in Baltimore and San Francisco, which have byes this week.

Baltimore's Lamar Jackson is a former first-round pick, 32nd overall in 2018. He's the third-highest-paid player in NFL history at $52 million a year.

San Francisco's Brock Purdy was the last pick of the last round in 2022. He's the 91st-highest-paid quarterback of 2023. His average salary of $934,252 ranks 11 notches below Vikings third-stringer Jaren Hall ($1,029,818).

Six of the 14 playoff quarterbacks were drafted in the first round by their current team. Besides the 27-year-old Jackson, there's 28-year-old Patrick Mahomes in Kansas City (10th, 2017), 27-year-old Josh Allen in Buffalo (seventh, 2018) and three guys making their playoff starting debuts: 25-year-old Tua Tagovailoa in Miami (fifth, 2020), 25-year-old Jordan Love in Green Bay (26th, 2020) and 22-year-old rookie C.J. Stroud in Houston (second, 2023).

Love and his coach, Matt LaFleur, reached the playoffs in Year 1 of the post-Favre/Rodgers era in Green Bay. They did it after Love sat for three seasons.

Stroud took another route. He and his coach, DeMeco Ryans, leaped into the fray together from Day 1. The result was a seven-win improvement and the distinction of being the first coach and quarterback of the Super Bowl era to reach the playoffs together as rookies.

The playoffs start Saturday afternoon at Houston. Standing opposite of Stroud is Cleveland's Joe Flacco, who turns 39 next week and was out of the league before the Browns needed a fourth starting quarterback to make it through their season.

Flacco went 4-1. What he and the Browns did — posting 11 wins with a league-high 37 turnovers and four quarterbacks starting multiple games — nullifies the primary excuses being made for the Vikings' league-worst six-game slide to end this season.

Two of the 14 playoff quarterbacks were acquired via trade — for each other. The Rams' Super Bowl champion Matthew Stafford returns to Detroit on Sunday night to face Jared Goff, who's trying to post the Lions' first playoff win since Jan. 5, 1992.

The Eagles' Jalen Hurts (second round), Pittsburgh's Mason Rudolph (third) and the Cowboys' Dak Prescott (fourth) also were drafted by their current teams.

Hurts, the fourth-highest paid player in NFL history ($51 million average), takes his slumping Eagles into Tampa to face the surging Buccaneers and quarterback Baker Mayfield, a guy the Bucs got for a one-year, $4 million prove-it deal in free agency.

Rudolph travels to Buffalo for a battle between teams that fired their offensive coordinators during the season. The Bills' Allen, a $43-million-a-year superstar, won five straight as Buffalo clinched its division. Meanwhile, Rudolph is making $1 million in the last year of his contract and was a backup until starting and winning the last three games to help Mike Tomlin reach the playoffs and become the league's longest-tenured head coach.

You'd think Tomlin would be safe. He hasn't had a losing season in 17 years as Steelers coach. He's won a Lombardi Trophy. And his employer has had only three head coaches since 1969.

But Tomlin also hasn't won a playoff game in seven years. And we just saw what happened to the last guy who stood atop the NFL's list of Coaches Who Have Not Been Fired … For Now.

about the writer

about the writer

Mark Craig

Sports reporter

Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

See More