Old nemesis Max Scherzer harms Twins again, this time in a Blue Jays victory

Max Scherzer, a nightmare for Minnesota while with Detroit, pitched Toronto to a 10-4 win over the Twins. Joe Ryan struggled for a second straight start.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
August 26, 2025 at 1:57AM
Blue Jays starting pitcher Max Scherzer delivers against the Twins on Monday night in Toronto. He gave up four runs in six innings and got the win. (Frank Gunn/The Associated Press)

Longtime Twins fans could be forgiven if they felt a familiar feeling of dread Monday night.

Yep, Max Scherzer lives.

The future Hall of Famer, a recurring nightmare for Minnesota while with the Detroit Tigers more than a decade ago, allowed four hits over six innings Monday at Rogers Centre, helping the first-place Blue Jays rout Joe Ryan and the Twins 10-4.

It was the Twins’ third consecutive loss and 11th in their last 14 games, dropping them to a season-worst 13 games below break-even at 59-72.

From 2011 to 2014, Scherzer started 13 games against the Twins for Detroit and the Tigers won 12 of them, with Scherzer credited with nine victories. He finally picked up No. 10 on Monday after an 11-year interim in which Scherzer won 129 other games for five different teams, two Cy Young Awards and a pair of World Series titles.

Haven’t missed him much, have you?

ADVERTISEMENT

Only Matt Wallner had much success against the 41-year-old righthander, twice connecting for long home runs and driving in a season-high three runs. Wallner ambushed a first-pitch slider in the fourth inning, driving it 419 feet and into the seats in right-center. It was Wallner’s 18th homer of the season — and his 13th coming with no teammates on base.

Two innings later, with Trevor Larnach on second base, Wallner again took Scherzer’s first pitch deep, this time blasting a belt-high fastball 432 feet onto the second level down the right-field line for No. 19.

The rest of the Twins lineup, though, went a combined 2-for-20 against Scherzer, both of them singles, as he improved to 5-2 for the Jays, who improved to 43-21 at Rogers Centre.

Ryan might someday be in Scherzer’s class as a pitcher, but he has had a rough past week. After allowing five runs in four innings last Tuesday against the Athletics, Ryan surrendered four runs in the first inning and another in the second, putting the slumping Twins down early. Five of the first seven Blue Jays to bat reached base, with All-Star catcher Alejandro Kirk smacking a two-run homer.

Twins pitcher Joe Ryan, right, reacts as Toronto's Bo Bichette rounds the bases on teammate Alejandro Kirk's two-run home run in the first inning Monday night. (Frank Gunn/The Associated Press)

Andrés Giménez led off the second with a home run of his own, his first since July 1. Giménez then sparked a two-out rally in the fourth inning, singling and stealing second base, where he could score on George Springer’s single.

Ryan gave up six runs over five innings — 11 total runs in back-to-back starts ties his career worst, something that hadn’t happened since 2023 — but Wallner’s second home run closed the gap to 6-4.

It wasn’t close for long. Brooks Kriske relieved him in the sixth inning and walked two batters to load the bases. With two outs and one strike from escaping the jam, Kriske left a splitter hanging across the middle. Nathan Lukes hit a hot grounder to center field that brought home two runs, and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. followed with a two-run single.

It marks the 30th time this season — and fifth game in a row — that the Twins have allowed seven or more runs in a game. They are 2-28 in those games.

The visit to downtown Toronto is also a reunion with Louie Varland and Ty France, traded by the Twins on July 31 in a deal that brought them injured outfielder Alan Roden and minor league pitcher Kendry Rojas. Both ex-Twins spent time talking with their former teammates during batting practice before the game.

Varland warmed up briefly while the game was close, but once the Blue Jays widened the gap, he did not pitch. France went 0-for-4 as Toronto’s first baseman.

about the writer

about the writer

Phil Miller

Reporter

Phil Miller has covered the Twins for the Minnesota Star Tribune since 2013. Previously, he covered the University of Minnesota football team, and from 2007-09, he covered the Twins for the Pioneer Press.

See Moreicon

More from Twins

See More
card image
Mike Janes

Winokur, a 6-foot-6 shortstop and center fielder, hit .226 with 17 homers, 68 RBI and 26 stolen bases in high Class A this year.

card image
card image